• Ragdoll Slaughter V4
    44 replies, posted
  • [QUOTE=simsfreak63;34865363]I love how you people work. Instead of attacking the issue at hand you come at me with personal attacks that have literally nothing to do with what we are discussing. I ask that you stop with the Ad hominem. I didn't even play this guy's map. I don't know if what he did was an improvisation or a straight up rip. Point is, Since he produced this map, both his and the original map have reached the popular downloads page. This map- which is no longer even available by the original publisher- Has achieved popularity it hasn't had for years. The original publisher of the map has not been heard from for years, and we may very well never hear from him again. He produced a great work, and it'd be selfish of anyone to deprive the public of what he'd done simply because we couldin't get approval for it. If he were to return and complain, I'm sure we would comply with his wishes. Should we condemn those who publish shakespeare because we didn't ask him if it was ok? What about the newly-popular spinoffs such as "Gnomeo and Juliet"? It was a bad movie, sure. But it created interest in one of the greatest artists of old, and anyone who thinks that is wrong is a bad person.[/QUOTE] Remaking a book, play or movie is ENTIRELY different from copyinjg and editing a map! You really have no idea what the fuck you're talking about. Comparing these 2 situations is like comparing Borrowing to Stealing and saying the two are the same. I suggest you stop posting here, before you say something even more ludicrously stupid.
  • I think the most irony here was at one point a V4 was in progress by the original author [url]http://www.facepunch.com/threads/890145[/url]
  • OP should make an entirely new map, but honestly I think gore mod or whatever it is kind of dumb. A bunch of red strings isn't gore
  • It you want gore, push a starving lion into the house of lords. You get gore, we get rid of a bunch of overpaid foolds with more money than sense.
  • Here is the PM i sent to swerik (the original author) I modded you map The Ragdoll Slaughter V3 I Added 2 New Traps and make Modded one I published it on the Gmod.org Website and the Toybox I will remove them if you want Ill give you the Vmf If you want .. I do not take any Credit For that work Here is the Forum Thread [url]http://www.facepunch.com/threads/1164460[/url] and here is the Download link [url]http://www.garrysmod.org/downloads/?a=view&id=128450[/url] I am just waiting for an Answer to know if I have the Right to keep Sharing it I gave all the Credits to you :)
  • [QUOTE=pac0master;34883718]Here is the PM i sent to swerik (the original author) I modded you map The Ragdoll Slaughter V3 I Added 2 New Traps and make Modded one I published it on the Gmod.org Website and the Toybox I will remove them if you want Ill give you the Vmf If you want .. I do not take any Credit For that work Here is the Forum Thread [url]http://www.facepunch.com/threads/1164460[/url] and here is the Download link [url]http://www.garrysmod.org/downloads/?a=view&id=128450[/url] I am just waiting for an Answer to know if I have the Right to keep Sharing it I gave all the Credits to you :)[/QUOTE] What the shit, you cannot do that, man. Asking for permission is not the same as what you did, which is doing whatever you want and telling an unused account to stop you if it can. Big, big difference.
  • Putting this for the record, rule 3 in the sticky 3. [b]Don't post decompiled or edited versions of other maps without explicit permission from the maker of the original map.[/b] Otherwise, don't post other people's maps and claim they're yours. If you post someone else's map give them credit.
  • [QUOTE=Pyth;34884497]and claim they're yours. If you post someone else's map give them credit.[/QUOTE] Exacly what i am doing I give Credit to him and NEVER Claimed it To be mine . I just worked on few hours and wanted to share it because i never seen an other version I know its not the Best thing to do but well i just wanted to share this because there is a lots of people who probably wanted something New I am working on My verion (all made by me) and erase this map The Author is active on Steam so im trying to contact him from there now
  • [QUOTE=pac0master;34887064]Exacly what i am doing I give Credit to him and NEVER Claimed it To be mine . I just worked on few hours and wanted to share it because i never seen an other version I know its not the Best thing to do but well i just wanted to share this because there is a lots of people who probably wanted something New I am working on My verion (all made by me) and erase this map The Author is active on Steam so im trying to contact him from there now[/QUOTE] I'm done, really. Done with this thread, done with you. Either you're blind or an idiot, because you missed the bolded part, which applies to you. The part you decided to reply to does not apply to you, it applies to people directly uploading the original versions of other maps without giving the creator credit. Your edit makes that an unoriginal version. If you still can't see that you're wrong, I really do feel bad for you. And if you finally understand you're wrong, save what's left of your anally raped dignity and take down your map until you get permission.
  • You should be ashamed, Pac0. You've lost my respect, this thread is just a plain waste of time.
  • I'm done reasoning. If you had a single little cell in your body that was nice you would ask a mod to lock the thread, remove this from toybox, and anywhere you have uploaded it.
  • You are right ... Sry for posting it i just wanted people to try something else .. gonna remove it after all i will probably not be able to contact the original author