Underrated games; ie Your friend saying: Fuck earthbound, I wanna play Call of Duty!

[UpchuckNorris]

^Title

And do you ever feel like punching someone when you hear remarks like this?

My picks are

Yoshi's Island
&
Earthbound

I would prepare a noose.

[Mr Flexi]

I do believe there is already several of these threads.

On topic though; The Saboteur didn't do as well as it should have.

[Sobotnik]

Republic the Revolution
Evil Genius
Railroad tycoon 3

[DatMeg]

Nethack

[Jorori]

- Ufouria: Is a cute Metroidvania that doesn't get too much general attention
- Shantae: It has a "Castlevania: Simon's Quest"-esque gameplay and is a pretty nice Game Boy Color game