"The system fires a reform card through email, sharing the chat log of the offending player (we scrub other players’ names and chat logs) and the punishment for the behavior"
I'm sorry what? Shouldn't they just highlight the player and show the others? They might have agitated the person, being responsible for the toxic behaviour in the first place.
Seeing as this is an automatic system I doubt it actually checks the other players' chatlog and tries to see if they played any role in it. If they are a group of friends or just didn't get reported but this person did, then they get to walk freely?
[QUOTE=dgg;47807113]
I'm sorry what? Shouldn't they just highlight the player and show the others? They might have agitated the person, being responsible for the toxic behaviour in the first place.[/QUOTE]
There's no excuse for being toxic though. If someone was being toxic to you, you can easily mute them in the game, so you can't see what they're saying, ignore them, so you won't play with them ever again, and report them, so that only they will get the ban. If you end up being toxic back to them, you are practically asking to get a report as well, as you are ruining it for the other players in the game as well, as no one wants to see two idiots fighting over nothing.
[QUOTE]Seeing as this is an automatic system I doubt it actually checks the other players' chatlog and tries to see if they played any role in it. If they are a group of friends or just didn't get reported but this person did, then they get to walk freely?[/QUOTE]
Actually, before this they had something called a tribunal, which was automated, and actually checked the other players' chatlogs. According to this, this sounds like an updated version of that. Plus, if at least one person reports everyone involved in the harrassment, then everyone involved would get a report.
[QUOTE=Krandel;47807247]There's no excuse for being toxic though. If someone was being toxic to you, you can easily mute them in the game, so you can't see what they're saying, ignore them, so you won't play with them ever again, and report them, so that only they will get the ban. If you end up being toxic back to them, you are practically asking to get a report as well, as you are ruining it for the other players in the game as well, as no one wants to see two idiots fighting over nothing.
Actually, before this they had something called a tribunal, which was automated, and actually checked the other players' chatlogs. According to this, this sounds like an updated version of that. Plus, if at least one person reports everyone involved in the harrassment, then everyone involved would get a report.[/QUOTE]
Wasn't tribunal like the CS:GO Overwatch system, as in you had players looking through the reports?
[QUOTE=Confuzzed Otto;47807254]Wasn't tribunal like the CS:GO Overwatch system, as in you had players looking through the reports?[/QUOTE]
Yes, pretty much.
yeah the tribunal was player judged, you didnt get to watch the games but you were given the chatlogs and their score across multiple games and had to decide whether they were worth punishing.
Then they switched to a simpler system that was essentially reported enough -> banned, or more usually just chat restricted (to avoid false bans due to excessive reports), which they kinda slowly improved over time
I think this isn't a change to how the system detects bad players, but a change to the feedback the system gives. In the tribunal system, when you were banned you were given the same tribunal log everyone reviewed. In the newer system you got little more than a notice saying "you were reported" post-game if enough people report you. If you did get punished there wasn't any reason given as to why, no specific game blamed, and the user who reported you got no feedback on their actions either
now it'll give you a chat log (similar to the old tribunal system) if you were punished shwoing why you were banned and some sort of positive message if someone you reported is punished
[QUOTE=Confuzzed Otto;47807254]Wasn't tribunal like the CS:GO Overwatch system, as in you had players looking through the reports?[/QUOTE]
I think you only had to be level 30 in LoL to have Tribunal rights, though. In CS:GO you gotta have a certain amount of ranked games or something like that.
[QUOTE=Keychain;47808375]I think you only had to be level 30 in LoL to have Tribunal rights, though. In CS:GO you gotta have a certain amount of ranked games or something like that.[/QUOTE]
Around 160 games and you must be Gold Nova+
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.