• Shacknews Chatty Community's Top 100 PC Games of All-Time: #10-1
    24 replies, posted
[url]http://www.shacknews.com/article/86485/shacknews-chatty-communitys-top-100-pc-games-of-all-time-10-1[/url]
Half life 2 wasn't THAT good imo
[QUOTE=martijnp3000;46089243]Half life 2 wasn't THAT good imo[/QUOTE] Yeah I found the middle part to be ultimately forgettable and I haven't touched it again since, but then again all this boils down to is someone's opinion. He's neither right or wrong putting it at the top position. I would personally have the three Bioshock games at the top if I could but again that's my opinion.
Eh, wasn't a crap selection but could have been a lot better. Better than most of these shitty lists, but nowhere near good.
Half Life 2 isn't THAT good TBH, it's definetly deserves a spot in the top 40, but not #1
Personally, I think Half Life 2 is better for what it started (but it's more due to the engine really) than the game itself, however, the game was and still is very memorable for me, especially the episodics, I'm not sure I'd place it on my top list (I feel like C&C Renegade was the number one for me, followed by UT99, oh and Svencoop, if that even counts)
Skyrim at #8 Absolutely disgusting.
No Serious Sam in the entire list. Disappointment
They could have switched out Skyrim for just about anything else really.
HL2 represents Source so for that reason I'd accept it, but the game itself isn't that great. Just what it started is amazing.
[QUOTE=Propane Addict;46089826]Skyrim at #8 Absolutely disgusting.[/QUOTE] It has its flaws, but to me Skyrim is a one-of-a-kind experience.
[QUOTE=SEKCobra;46089995]HL2 represents Source so for that reason I'd accept it, but the game itself isn't that great. Just what it started is amazing.[/QUOTE] HL2 was good when it came out. It's just aged horribly.
Does anyone ever enter one of these games lists news threads expecting to agree 100%? It's always and always the same shit.
Half Life 2 blew everything out of the water when it came out. It deserves its spot. Graphics, animations, physics. It did so much right. [QUOTE=Protocol7;46090033]HL2 was good when it came out. It's just aged horribly.[/QUOTE] Half Life 2 aged magnificent. It still looks good and plays good. Try to compare it to other titles from 2004.
I would have given Deus Ex #1
This entire list is a popularity contest. [QUOTE=Protocol7;46090033]HL2 was good when it came out. It's just aged horribly.[/QUOTE] Just because it's 10 years old doesn't stop it from still being good. Citizen Kane is 80+ years old doesn't stop it from being good.
Diablo 2 was a great game
Where the fuck was Myst?
[QUOTE=pentium;46102125]Where the fuck was Myst?[/QUOTE] #85
half life 2 as best pc game ever really discounting the numerous mods, it's a rather uninspired linear shooter with the only gimmick being the gravity gun. its a great game, but number 1? lmao.
[QUOTE=Loadingue;46090029]It has its flaws, but to me Skyrim is a one-of-a-kind experience.[/QUOTE] Skyrim got no combat system at all and the greatest lack of scale a game has ever had. The great battle of Whiterun is eight guys hitting another eight guys in the head with swords. That's a siege. For a major city.
[QUOTE=Dermock;46103422]half life 2 as best pc game ever really discounting the numerous mods, it's a rather uninspired linear shooter with the only gimmick being the gravity gun. its a great game, but number 1? lmao.[/QUOTE] It seems uninspired now but it was pretty fresh when it came out.
What happend to the blind Half Life 2 love when it was voted game of the decade?
[QUOTE=Dermock;46103422]half life 2 as best pc game ever really discounting the numerous mods, it's a rather uninspired linear shooter with the only gimmick being the gravity gun. its a great game, but number 1? lmao.[/QUOTE] Some games are less about bringing something new to the table than bringing what's already been done to near-perfection. [editline]30th September 2014[/editline] Not saying it's my favorite game ever, but that's hardly because it was "uninspired and had few gimmicks".
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.