Skart - Post-rock/electronic song, please give feedbacks
16 replies, posted
So I made this song in Reason 4, listen to it all the way through and tell me what you think.
[media]http://soundcloud.com/gabester/skart[/media]
It changes up a bit throughout the song, the last few minutes are the best part I think.
Oh come on, can someone at least listen to it?
ho my god
at the midway point where it picks up a bit, and towards the end where the piano/keyboard thing comes in
:gizz:
a++ shit as usual bro
dude wtf, why do I keep getting ignored in here? Everyone else's threads get like a dozen replies in a few days, I have one and it's because I linked venom to the thread :| Is my music really that bad? Do I have to do something special to get feedback? I've given other people feedback, I don't know why I'm still being ignored.
not really my style but it seems good
[QUOTE=Penis Colada;29291041]dude wtf, why do I keep getting ignored in here? Everyone else's threads get like a dozen replies in a few days, I have one and it's because I linked venom to the thread :| Is my music really that bad? Do I have to do something special to get feedback? I've given other people feedback, I don't know why I'm still being ignored.[/QUOTE]
Most people only enjoy criticism. Since your songs are not easy to criticize, most people probably just listen and leave.
It really is a nice piece of work.
That was pretty damn good, well done man.
Thanks guys, it means a lot :)
Good background music, but as usual I'm way to ADHD to listen to it without doing something else at the same time so I can't provide any specific feedback. I never heard anything bad, and sure it isn't OMAGAWD AMAZING but it's really good, and I like it a lot. Good job mayin.
Equalize it so you get more of a high end. Right now it sounds like I'm hearing it through the wall. Also, tweak the mix a tiny bit because your sounds aren't blending together too well, it's usually one covering up the other until it gets loud enough to break through. This may be from over-compression as well, not sure. Just give it a little mastering, and it should sound great!
[editline]21st April 2011[/editline]
I have Reason 5 + Record 1.5, so I can give it some studio quality mastering for you, but I wouldn't be able to send you the save file for it because the newer version's saves are incompatible with 4's. PM me if you're interested.
I use Reason 5, saves would be compatible. I'd kinda rather do it myself though. You're totally right about the high end being too little, I'll work on that.
I can make a temp save to show you how things are done if you need help with it.
Lemme know if this is any better:
[media]http://soundcloud.com/gabester/skart[/media]
[editline]22nd April 2011[/editline]
fuck, I think the Rhodes is too scratchy now or something
The mix is very muffled-sounding, you need to make each instrument stand out more
This any better? I'm listening to it/mixing it with very good headphones so it's hard to tell if I'm improving it. If I could mix while I'm listening to it in my car I'd be able to improve it more, since it does sound quite muffled in there. I [i]have[/i] mixed a lot of the highs out of instruments just because to me it sounds better that way, it makes for a nice meaty low end texture but I'm not sure if that's a good thing. It sounds good to me anyways.
[media]http://soundcloud.com/gabester/skart[/media]
Sounding a lot better already, but it still has a ways to go. You're on the right track. Give your drums some higher EQ as well.
Not normally my thing, but this really ain't bad! The change of chords towards the end is heavenly! and the little synth solo is the perfect way to finish :D I'd love to hear some more drum beat changes in it personally, I think you got all the other changes right though :D good stuff dude, good stuff :)
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.