What do you guys think of GTAV in 4K? Edit: This video was made using the PC version of the game. Each system is tweaked as close as PC would let me. The benchmark tool is why I even made this video.
[video=youtube;M2hMmdwtL5I]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M2hMmdwtL5I[/video]
Some people are upset I did not clarify this:
[img]http://puu.sh/hdZ9M/0ae6026927.jpg[/img]
except the 3 videos are all shot on a pc?
[QUOTE=camper182 V2;47527176]except the 3 videos are all shot on a pc?[/QUOTE]
They use close to the same settings as the consoles.
[QUOTE=xcaboose;47527193]They use close to the same settings as the consoles.[/QUOTE]
Except the specifications are different to the PC.
[QUOTE=Digimutant;47527207]Except the specifications are different to the PC.[/QUOTE]
Sorry this does not meet the "Expert" specifications. This was the best way to show how the graphics compare sibe-by-side. Plus it was all shot in 4K. I enjoyed making the video so I'm happy.
[QUOTE=xcaboose;47527247]Sorry this does not meet the "Expert" specifications. This was the best way to show how the graphics compare sibe-by-side. Plus it was all shot in 4K. [B]I enjoyed making the video so I'm happy.[/B][/QUOTE]
what a childish thing to say.
[QUOTE=Hogie bear;47527273]what a childish thing to say.[/QUOTE]
Yeah, expressing human feelings. So childish. If you don't like the video dislike and leave. All I asked was "What do you guys think of GTAV in 4K?"
I can tell you already, quite easily, that the "PS3" version on your video is nowhere near close to the PS3 version. Like, at all.
[QUOTE=xcaboose;47527336]Yeah, expressing human feelings. So childish. If you don't like the video dislike and leave. All I asked was "What do you guys think of GTAV in 4K?"[/QUOTE]
well, you posted a comparison that is hardly a comparison video at all. When you were told that, you didn't take the criticism very well.
[QUOTE=Bugga12;47527357]I can tell you already, quite easily, that the "PS3" version on your video is nowhere near close to the PS3 version. Like, at all.[/QUOTE]
I know. I tried to get it as close as I could.
[QUOTE=HumanAbyss;47527376]well, you posted a comparison that is hardly a comparison video at all. When you were told that, you didn't take the criticism very well.[/QUOTE]
I was just explaining my method.
[QUOTE=xcaboose;47527247]Sorry this does not meet the "Expert" specifications. This was the best way to show how the graphics compare sibe-by-side. Plus it was all shot in 4K. I enjoyed making the video so I'm happy.[/QUOTE]
Wasn't really a good comparison then. Hardly even a comparison.
[QUOTE=xcaboose;47527430]I know. I tried to get it as close as I could.
I was just explaining my method.[/QUOTE]
Yes, and explaining it showed even more so how the "comparison" wasn't at all a comparison. i get what you were attempting to do, and some people may be being hostile, but I'm not, i'm just telling you WHY people are reacting as they are and how you're part of that chain.
Point being, don't post or create a "Comparison" video when the comparison is not accurate or representative.
I couldn't even get past your shitty intro.
Are you actually 12?
Seriously?
Youtube compression voids everything
how bout that stutter son
what's the point of a comparison video if you don't actually use the system you're comparing it to
[editline]14th April 2015[/editline]
"i made this big mac as close as i could to the actual big mac from mcdonald's, so i'm gonna compare it to my home made burger"
[QUOTE=BeardyDuck;47528396]what's the point of a comparison video if you don't actually use the system you're comparing it to
[editline]14th April 2015[/editline]
"i made this big mac as close as i could to the actual big mac from mcdonald's, so i'm gonna compare it to my home made burger"[/QUOTE]
"but I made it for fun so fuck you anyway."
If you can't get actual ps3 / ps4 footage for this comparison, [I]please say so.[/I]
I understand that you changed the settings to closely match the consoles but comparisons are all about facts, and the fact is that a PC with settings matching closely to a ps3 / ps4 is NOT a ps3 / ps4.
If it were me, I would've just compared different PC settings at different resolutions; at least then it would be true (and helpful to people judging what GPU to buy for this game maybe?). But for now it's not really helpful to anyone weighing the graphic differences between the consoles (besides it being on YouTube) because it just isn't accurate.
Like, I don't even care if you have an intro or spend too much time on post-production or whatever, the content itself is what matters first.
[sp]also you chose to post it on facepunch of all places, so there's bound to be CC. if you keep ignoring them it isn't going to make you a better videomaker.[/sp]
[QUOTE=Octopod;47529198]If you can't get actual ps3 / ps4 footage for this comparison, [I]please say so.[/I]
I understand that you changed the settings to closely match the consoles but comparisons are all about facts, and the fact is that a PC with settings matching closely to a ps3 / ps4 is NOT a ps3 / ps4.
If it were me, I would've just compared different PC settings at different resolutions; at least then it would be true (and helpful to people judging what GPU to buy for this game maybe?). But for now it's not really helpful to anyone weighing the graphic differences between the consoles (besides it being on YouTube) because it just isn't accurate.
Like, I don't even care if you have an intro or spend too much time on post-production or whatever, the content itself is what matters first.
[sp]also you chose to post it on facepunch of all places, so there's bound to be CC. if you keep ignoring them it isn't going to make you a better videomaker.[/sp][/QUOTE]
I agree. That would have been better. I'm going to be back. But next time it won't be this shit. I'm working on some machinima ideas. Hopefully I can make a better impression then.
[QUOTE=xcaboose;47529716]I agree. That would have been better. I'm going to be back. But next time it won't be this shit. I'm working on some machinima ideas. Hopefully I can make a better impression then.[/QUOTE]
Good luck to you, and keep having fun.
This had the potential to be very tongue in cheek. You could have turned everything as low as it would go, put it at some bonkers low res, like 480 or even 240, and had that be your console comparison.
[QUOTE=Tmaxx;47530033]This had the potential to be very tongue in cheek. You could have turned everything as low as it would go, put it at some bonkers low res, like 480 or even 240, and had that be your console comparison.[/QUOTE]
Shoulda just used San Andreas gameplay as the console footage.
To make it as realistic as possible the "PS3" footage should have been in 720p capped at a cinematic silky smooth 20FPS. The PS4 version of course being perfectly fine 900p at 28FPS.
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.