Everything Wrong with Fellowship of The Ring - General

[video=youtube;xLoobrbKepE]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLoobrbKepE[/video] Couldn't help but laugh at the "after credits".

This is sillly.

movie sins guy once again demonstrates he knows absolutely nothing about the material he is trying to criticize. more cringeworthy than when he asked a load of dumb questions about pacific rim, all of which were answered by 'because it's a monster film being cool'

Damnit man, those weren't orcs, those were goblins!

You guys take this waaaay to seriously.

[QUOTE=Cloak Raider;43066310]movie sins guy once again demonstrates he knows absolutely nothing about the material he is trying to criticize. more cringeworthy than when he asked a load of dumb questions about pacific rim, all of which were answered by 'because it's a monster film being cool'[/QUOTE] I think that's half the point.

[QUOTE=Cloak Raider;43066310]movie sins guy once again demonstrates he knows absolutely nothing about the material he is trying to criticize. more cringeworthy than when he asked a load of dumb questions about pacific rim, all of which were answered by 'because it's a monster film being cool'[/QUOTE] you do realize he's almost always 100% sarcastic, right

[QUOTE=Cloak Raider;43066310]movie sins guy once again demonstrates he knows absolutely nothing about the material he is trying to criticize. more cringeworthy than when he asked a load of dumb questions about pacific rim, all of which were answered by 'because it's a monster film being cool'[/QUOTE] [url=https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qvkZ8sCd5EI]Watch this.[/url]

[QUOTE=Zukriuchen;43066444]you do realize he's almost always 100% sarcastic, right[/QUOTE] even if its 100% sarcastic that doesn't mean it also needs to be 0% funny opinions etc I dunno, I think for it to even work as sarcasm, there has to be an ounce of truth behind what he says otherwise it just comes across as a guy having no idea

It's not really sarcasm. All the things he mentions in these videos are legitimate flaws. This does not mean that the movies are bad. It doesn't even signify that there are bad elements in these movies. Find me any movie ever, and I can point out 101 logical faults or inconsistencies in all of them. There is no movie ever that is completely consistent and flawless. These videos are just fun because they point out some of the defects that we probably never thought about.

[QUOTE=Explosions;43066620]It's not really sarcasm. All the things he mentions in these videos are legitimate flaws. This does not mean that the movies are bad. It doesn't even signify that there are bad elements in these movies. Find me any movie ever, and I can point out 101 logical faults or inconsistencies in all of them. There is no movie ever that is completely consistent and flawless. These videos are just fun because they point out some of the defects that we probably never thought about.[/QUOTE] not all of them are legitimate flaws, a lot of them are just nitpicking and/or joking around. and it is sarcasm, because he implies it makes the movies bad, which is where the humor comes from

[QUOTE=Explosions;43066620]It's not really sarcasm. All the things he mentions in these videos are legitimate flaws. This does not mean that the movies are bad. It doesn't even signify that there are bad elements in these movies. Find me any movie ever, and I can point out 101 logical faults or inconsistencies in all of them. There is no movie ever that is completely consistent and flawless. These videos are just fun because they point out some of the defects that we probably never thought about.[/QUOTE] How is it a legitimate flaw that for example, the intro screen is dark? Not even 1/10th of these are legitimate flaws, but as it has been pointed out they ain't being serious.