• My Little Pony Friendship is Magic Review
    15 replies, posted
edit: Please watch the second video before judging me. Okay well this is my review of My Little Pony Friendship is Magic. The first video is kind of a partial "let's watch" video of the first 2 episodes of the show. Part 1 is my actual serious review. Please don't turn this into a Brony discussion thread I just wanted feedback on my review. First Impressions [video=youtube;MQmxrcTAP-g]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MQmxrcTAP-g[/video] Review [video=youtube;47X7nzEVC0A]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=47X7nzEVC0A[/video] Tell me what you think please. I'm planning more videos and I need to know what to improve.
uhhh....wow.....uhhh...wow....uhhh....wow....wow thats....is basically what i got
[QUOTE=Kai-ryuu;31966148]uhhh....wow.....uhhh...wow....uhhh....wow....wow thats....is basically what i got[/QUOTE] Yeah I did say that in the video. Thanks for the input. :v:
Thought it was a decent review, but I thought you could have done what I've seen many reviewers do and delve a little bit into each main character, not much, just a little. Then again this was a review of the show as a whole. So, I don't know. EDIT: But yeah, with the characters you could have commented on how they're underwritten, overwritten, too basic, etc. Honestly, I like how they gave them pretty obvious flaws. Twilight always goes by the book. Fluttershy is too shy to speak up on anything. Rarity doesn't want to do any actual manual labor, unless it involves clothing. Rainbow Dash always needs attention. Apple Jack trys to hard. Pinkie Pie thinks everything can be solved with a party, and did snap in the show when no one showed up to one of her parties. Just some examples.
[QUOTE=Dracon;31966490]Thought it was a decent review, but I thought you could have done what I've seen many reviewers do and delve a little bit into each main character, not much, just a little. Then again this was a review of the show as a whole. So, I don't know.[/QUOTE] Yeah I was going to do that and I don't know why I decided not to. I know I should have though. [QUOTE=Dracon;31966490] EDIT: But yeah, with the characters you could have commented on how they're underwritten, overwritten, too basic, etc. Honestly, I like how they gave them pretty obvious flaws. Twilight always goes by the book. Fluttershy is too shy to speak up on anything. Rarity doesn't want to do any actual manual labor, unless it involves clothing. Rainbow Dash always needs attention. Apple Jack trys to hard. Pinkie Pie thinks everything can be solved with a party, and did snap in the show when no one showed up to one of her parties. Just some examples.[/QUOTE] Yeah I should have gone more in depth and all I did was give opinions. I appreciate the criticism and I will definitely do this for the next show or movie I review.
[quote]Thought I'd watch the show, because no other guy has done so before.[/quote] Such an understatement.
[QUOTE=FreezingStorm;31966825]Such an understatement.[/QUOTE] That was a joke. :) Apparently it wasn't funny.
You people just can't leave people's interests alone without making fun of them like a bunch of immature children
[QUOTE=Clementine;31968247]You people just can't leave people's interests alone without making fun of them like a bunch of immature children[/QUOTE] Did you watch part 2? I actually make an attempt to do an honest review of it. Part 1 isn't a real review. It kind of just sums up what I thought when I first started watching it.
gay
[QUOTE=Clementine;31968247]You people just can't leave people's interests alone without making fun of them like a bunch of immature children[/QUOTE] did you ever consider that maybe he's trying to make an honest review
I stopped the video when you started saying "Oh...Wow...Wow...Oh..That's...Wow...Wow...Oh..Oh....Wow" over and over
[media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n3iErUm9Q3c[/media] brother....
guys, just watch the second video, first is a first impressions video, not a review.
Didn't watch the first video. Second video was excellent. I was expecting to watch some overly angry person calling fans manchildren and faggots. Or an overly enthusiastic fan explaining why it's oh so magically great and what not. And what I got was a reasonable review that reviewed the show, not the fans, and did it well. Well done. [editline]27th August 2011[/editline] Okay I actually found the first video hilarious
[QUOTE=Sherow_Xx;31972001]Didn't watch the first video. Second video was excellent. I was expecting to watch some overly angry person calling fans manchildren and faggots. Or an overly enthusiastic fan explaining why it's oh so magically great and what not. And what I got was a reasonable review that reviewed the show, not the fans, and did it well. Well done. [editline]27th August 2011[/editline] Okay I actually found the first video hilarious[/QUOTE] At least someone saw what I was trying to do. With the second video I mean. The first video is the one I don't give a shit about. [editline]27th August 2011[/editline] [QUOTE=Corporal Yippie;31971763][media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=n3iErUm9Q3c[/media] brother....[/QUOTE] Now I feel like a shameless ripoff. Though really it's not the whole video.
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.