Red Dead Redemption 2 Discussion - Games

Speaking of Bonnie, have you guys found the dead guy who was in love with her and tried to show his affection by getting rich and famous in RDR2 land or something?

After the events of the game. Note he said “before that I rode with a gang”

Post-ending spoilers: True, but we get to see a lot of that timespan. RDR1 takes place in 1911, RDR2 ends in 1907. Javier asks how John's "children" are (plural) when you chase him down in RDR1, so some of the gang would know about her.

I'm not even on chapter 6 yet, I barely started 5 and I'm suffering from it. Remember that certain collection mission? Probably there..?

*END OF CHAPTER 6 SPOILERS* Did anyone else run back into the building and shoot Agent Milton's corpse a few more times before getting on the horses with Sadie and Abigail? Because I sure did, and it felt great.

I just noticed, when you press down on the D-pad to see location information and temperature, the temperature isn't just for the area, it's for Arthur. If you stand next to a camp fire it goes up like 6 degrees, and if you go into a building it goes right up too. I noticed it when I was in a cold part of the map and when I walked into a building it came up and said "Arthur is too warm".

https://files.facepunch.com/forum/upload/109843/2a36672e-2dc6-429c-8429-617b0883ed8d/Red Dead Redemption 2_20181031143841.mp4

I absolutely love hitting "Antagonize", then "Defuse", then "Antagonize" over and over. "Looks like you're having a shit day" "What'd you say to me!?" "I'm only messing with ya" "Alright" "Yeah, you stupid"

Is there a substantial reason for carrying around animal carcasses? I only have one trapper revealed and I hate have to trek what feels like the entire map on horseback. Should I even be bothering with this for legendary animals, also.

You get paid for them. And you can donate them to the camp.

Legendary animals are the only ones that are really worth bothering with because their pelts, horns, teeth, feathers, etc give you unique outfits, trinkets, and talismans with stat bonuses.

Trying to look like good ol' Blondie. Had a mule too, but THOSE DAMN O'DRISCOLLS!! ambushed me whilst I was riding it back to Valentine and it despawned while I took care of them. Doesn't respawn AFAIK and you can only find new ones in New Austin. https://files.facepunch.com/forum/upload/109843/8bc16de0-61cb-4883-856c-8dc2f139baa8/Red Dead Redemption 2_20181101181525_1.png We need a poncho now Rockstar, c'mon

https://www.reddit.com/r/reddeadredemption/comments/9tcr04/im_just_waiting_for_my_horse_then/ I still don't know what hit me...

Damn, I just found a huge cave system behind the waterfall at Elysium Pool. It's sprawling with multiple ways to go and huge drops, goes deep beneath the earth. Stole a miner's helmet with a headlight in Annesburg and going exploring now, wish me luck!

Okay, I'm about to give up on this stranger interaction 5 or 6 times in, but I have to know do you ever find Gavin?

My Arthur has started holding hay real weird. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jbW4MSlf6hM At least he does his chores.

Is there a backstory to this that I missed? https://youtu.be/9w8IQKQli00?t=2

i don't believe so

Do you remember saving a woman from drowning?

I just ran into a weird bug where the people that were supposed to be following me were super slow, way behind me and they kept repeating their first line of dialogue "it's just up- it's just up- it's just up- it's just up ahead Arthur." Idk if I missed any important story bits because of it, but it was really annoying

I loaded my game last night and one of my horses turned into a default horse. Anyone else lose a horse this way?

I remember some people already encountered the KKK, but for anyone else who haven't yet and are tempted to just shoot them, don't. Just listen in and watch them (they're not hostile too so you can do it up close). Trust me it's worth it. They even have a second encounter you can get later afterwards that makes it even funnier.

Awww I blew them all with TNT the moment I saw them.

If you want to find out at least what happens During the first encounter, after they start burning the cross, the guy accidentally ignites himself, and ignites everyone else and they all run screaming and burning to death. The leader in the black robes gets upset and if he sees Arthur, he'll say leave him alone. You can even poke fun at him via interaction dialogue. The second time you meet them, they're trying to get another cross up, but they get crushed by it as they get it up. The leader gets upset again and Arthur can talk to the leader again and he'll say 'guess you guys get what you deserve'. The leader gets pissed off from this and tries to attack you with a knife, which afterwards you can go ahead and kill him.

I let the scene finish,killed all remaining guys and still got the second one. Read the letters.

Happened the same to me too. I finished the game a couple of days ago and it was honestly amazing, i don't really like open world games because of how the story can sometimes not make any sense if you do some quest before others or after some event but this game handled it perfectly. Definitely one of the best games of 2018.

Dang nice, including the leader? I really wanted to hear the entire possible conversation so I was weary to start shooting anyone even after they lit themselves on fire on the first one. I remember looting the ones that did get burned and found some letters and notes including about not letting women in and one written to someone's father on why he left his home and joined the klan.

Robbing trains is so much easier when they're over a large bridge and the law can't reach you.

So far, Mary-Beth is my favourite lady, she's got this friendly vibe to her (which obviously ties into her criminal activities) and she's just a nice character in general, looks cute, I'm at chapter 4, not long since got into it and I'm hoping for some more stuff with her. Didn't like when there was a mission on the map with her and it's you having a nice conversation with her and it gets cut off because shit's kicking off with Tilly, just let us talk please. Also some big ol' story spoiler talk here. Seriously not happy about Sean getting killed off like that, I liked him, he was a little shit but he was great to listen to and do stuff with, fucking Greys, arseholes; really wanted Arthur to punch Micah in his fucking face, Sean just got killed right in front of them and Micah's just mouthing off, how about shut up.