Welp, mnemo just told me that our submissions were forgotten and werent even reviewed. That kinda sucks.
[QUOTE=ScreamingGerbil;34659210]Welp, mnemo just told me that our submissions were forgotten and werent even reviewed. That kinda sucks.[/QUOTE]
And the Honorary "Woopsie-Daisy" Award goes to...
im surprised there are download links for these
[QUOTE=ScreamingGerbil;34659210]Welp, mnemo just told me that our submissions were forgotten and werent even reviewed. That kinda sucks.[/QUOTE]
Its kind of sad how disorganized this whole thing was.
I hope the next one is better organized.
Here's the concept art that was made for Major Tom.
[img]http://dl.dropbox.com/u/586461/Models/pyro-jetpack-concept.jpg[/img]
[QUOTE=Wowza!;34658465]I wonder why my model got rated so low for model and texture quality. I mean, it isn't as good as some of the other models, but it's not exactly shitty, either.
[T]http://cloud.steampowered.com/ugc/468608982357175218/827894698E88FEE8EB7B02159AF6E27E0DE0961F/[/T][/QUOTE]
In my opinion,I think it's too bland and boring.
[QUOTE=Totenkreuz;34659150]So who else didn't get a rating ?[/QUOTE]
In the Steam group they said there were 22 submissions, and 9 of them got a rating, plus 3 in this thread.
[QUOTE=ScreamingGerbil;34659210]Welp, mnemo just told me that our submissions were forgotten and werent even reviewed. That kinda sucks.[/QUOTE]
That definetly takes a stab at my pride. After they take near 3 weeks to do this....I mean really ?
I was not technically part of the competition, but I did make something for it.
[IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v730/emrfish6/as_v1-3_p1.png[/IMG]
[QUOTE=Wowza!;34658465]I wonder why my model got rated so low for model and texture quality. I mean, it isn't as good as some of the other models, but it's not exactly shitty, either.
[T]http://cloud.steampowered.com/ugc/468608982357175218/827894698E88FEE8EB7B02159AF6E27E0DE0961F/[/T][/QUOTE]
It's not terrible, it just needs a bit of work.
I wasn't a judge so take this with a grain of salt if you wish but the main problem I have with this weapon, aside from the absurd polycount which you already explained, is the texture.
The first problem is that there doesn't seem to be a phong mask and as a result it's too shiny.
The next problem is that the texture has almost no detail. No brush strokes, no edge highlights no anything. It's all just solid color. The only sort of detail is the meter.
The last problem I have is that it's just too gray. It needs more color to it.
There is also the lack of detail on the model it's self. There just isn't enough to make it interesting to look at.
Just keep trying. You'll get the hang of it.
[QUOTE=kenshin6;34659785]I was not technically part of the competition, but I did make something for it.
[IMG]http://img.photobucket.com/albums/v730/emrfish6/as_v1-3_p1.png[/IMG][/QUOTE]
Speaking of which, how did that NOT get in the top 10? It was awesome!
[QUOTE=Justnobody;34660700]Speaking of which, how did that NOT get in the top 10? It was awesome![/QUOTE]
"I was not part of the competition"
Man I thought the Spy satellite dish gun was friggin' cool looking. Apparently I was in the minority on this one.
[img]http://dl.dropbox.com/u/6993235/Experimental/Heavy/Pain%20Frequency_QColour.png[/img]
That's pretty much all the concept art I did for the pain frequency.
fuk da police.
Just to be clear, the 14 teams who sent in their items were all judged. Only daimao forgot to judge two teams, but he is judging them atm. Only three of the 7 judges wrote a review. Daimao wrote one for each catagory, the other two just wrote a small opinion. I think we will just put his reviews on the site.
Don't be afraid to contact the judges for questions about your models or post your questions here.
I am curious as to how mine stands against the others, but it isnt really that important.
Now wait a minute. So what about the other submissions? They don't get released and we won't have a chance to download them?
Congrats to the winnners! maybe next time have 5 winners.
I forgot mention that we have a small surprise for the winners and everyone who entered the competition.
Looking back on the specific results, kinda disappointed the 'pain frequency' didn't score higher in 'Does it fit TF2?'
Ah well, still pleased with the result none the less.
[editline]12th February 2012[/editline]
[QUOTE=Evil_Knevil;34662045]I forgot mention that we have a small surprise for the winners and everyone who entered the competition.[/QUOTE]
Tell me your mysteries.
[B][U]Important![/U][/B]
All submissions were rated and will be put on the website later this day, we just didn´t want to make you wait another day for the results, so we released the top-10 yesterday.
[B]The other submissions are going to be on the website too, as well as the download links.[/B]
We didn´t want to offend someone with our scores and we will try to bring the reviews that [I]were[/I] written to you as soon as possible.
As to the advice: you can see on the allocation of points in which category you have to improve.
Don´t be afraid to ask the judges about your item, they will answer your questions and give some useful advice ;)
Talk to you later today!
What the next "Modding Competition"? Monty Python? Pirates? Tiny guns for Heavy?
[QUOTE=Damian0358;34664048]What the next "Modding Competition"? Monty Python? Pirates? Tiny guns for Heavy?[/QUOTE]
Yes please, tiny weapons guy!
Still think it should be Superheroes & Supervillains theme. :v:
[QUOTE=Sharc;34664747]Still think it should be Superheroes & Supervillains theme. :v:[/QUOTE]
And not a single hero item was given to spy.
[QUOTE=Constructor;34665592]And not a single hero item was given to spy.[/QUOTE]
Team-colored tights would be glorious.
[QUOTE=Constructor;34665592]And not a single hero item was given to spy.[/QUOTE]
Inspector Gadget.
[QUOTE=Damian0358;34664048]What the next "Modding Competition"? Monty Python? [/QUOTE]
yesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesyesy
Trash weaponry, AKA 2x4 tech.
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.
