• Moderators you think shouldn't be
    202 replies, posted
MaxOfS2D for being french.
Rusty and Max
Max is obvious, I can't entirely agree with Megafan's modding too. Craptasket is a mix of douchebag and fucking hilarious so I can't really hate on him. I also don't think VeryNiceLady is a very nice lady.
I'll be honest, I have no problem with Rusty, it's not like he bans people for disagreeing with him. Max I don't really have a problem with either, he just needed time to find his feet, although a couple of his bans are a bit silly. All in all I don't mind who the mods are at the moment. [sp]Except for Garry, demod him ASAP[/sp]
Max is probably the worst.
[QUOTE=HoodedSniper;42341913]Rusty, he fucking defended Dead Space 3 and thinks his word is gospel, but honestly besides him just having terrible opinions and posts hes not a bad mod, its just he defended Dead Space 3 and thats pretty bad.[/QUOTE] lol, disliking a moderator cause he doesn't share your opinion
[QUOTE=HoodedSniper;42342192]Dead Space 3 is so fucking awful, im appalled you actually think its good. You just proved my point.[/QUOTE] waaa someone's opinion is different from yours >:(
Rusty's an asshole but he's a good mod and I haven't seen him ban anybody based on disagreeing with him yet.
My only issue with MaxofS2D are the 12 hour bans that he hands out like candy. If you're going to ban someone it should be something worth appealing. Though it seems 12 hour bans are the common ban now I guess?
imagine physically being enough of a dork to be appalled at someone and hate them as a mod for liking a video game you do not like ... actually why imagine it's right up there (have a look)
[QUOTE=Reds;42344322]Rusty's an asshole but he's a good mod and I haven't seen him ban anybody based on disagreeing with him yet.[/QUOTE] It's the only thing that's keeping him from being de-modded
i won two separate moderator elections, got upgraded to super mod, permabanned, unbanned, and re-supermodded. i think im doin alright [editline]30th September 2013[/editline] which is why i laugh every time someone says 'jesus christ how did you become a mod' because, gosh, how [i]didn't[/i] i?
[QUOTE=Reds;42344322]Rusty's an asshole but he's a good mod and I haven't seen him ban anybody based on disagreeing with him yet.[/QUOTE] Here's a fun game. Go to the Film & TV forum, disagree with Rusty and see how long it takes for him to start insulting you. Besides that, he's a generally cool dude. Can't say the same for MaxofS2D.
[QUOTE=BFG9000;42342953]I thought he was gold? I've been living under a rock[/QUOTE] He was demodded a long time ago, it was a joke :v:
I don't have anything against Max on a personal level, he seems like a nice guy, but I think he could be a little less trigger-happy with the bans. Though as far as I've seen it's not as bad anymore as back when he was just promoted to mod. Correct me if I'm wrong.
[QUOTE=triplej05;42343315]Whichever mod messaged my girlfriend on Facebook. Think it was Postal.[/QUOTE] nope lol, was probably rusty [editline]29th September 2013[/editline] no real reason for my assumption i just want to blame rusty
rusty is a p cool dude, check out this video of him in action [media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M0bY3AVun7I[/media]
[QUOTE=Rusty100;42342076]wtf, dead space 3 was probably the most fun i had playing a video game in that year, i don't even see any reason you would hate it. the writing isn't even bad enough, it's like b-movie level, which goes perfectly with it's genre and setting. good thing that has nothing to do with my moderation[/QUOTE] Attitude has literally everything to do with being a moderator
_
[QUOTE=kimr120;42346201]Replace Garry with a random moderator. Honestly I notice a bit of bias from some mods. Some have banned for simple opinions as "I don't like black people" or "I don't like transvestites because they scare me". The worst offenders are max and megafan. Sure if you say someone of a group should die only because they are themselves then you are clearly a good target for the banhammer. I don't care if you have different opinions and hate people who are racists or anti-gay. You should not label and ban a person for his phobia or hate as long he is moderately calm, Garry is the only that can ban anyone because their opinion differs from his. This is because he owns the forum.[/QUOTE] ehhh, saying stuff like "I don't like black people" is toeing the line. And as far as bans go, I'm still a little sore over Garry p-banning me for no reason, I had to beg like a bitch to get back :v:
[QUOTE=Ericson666;42346228]ehhh, saying stuff like "[B]I don't like black people[/B]" is toeing the line. And as far as bans go, I'm still a little sore over Garry p-banning me for no reason, I had to beg like a bitch to get back :v:[/QUOTE] Oh come on it's an opinion even if it is dumb and racist. EDIT: If you don't like it you can try to argue so he/she maybe will change their view on people who are different. Also as I said above garry can ban anyone because he owns the forum. He can even pull the plug on the servers because someone says or do something if he want so.
[QUOTE=kimr120;42346201]EDIT: A problem I have with a some other moderators I don't remember which don't give a warning, like saying "please don't say that or I need to ban you". Otherwise all mods are okey.[/QUOTE] There are rules, those themselves are a warning. If you break them, you get banned for breaking the rules. If you don't learn from getting banned, eventually, you'll get perma'd. So it's the users fault, not the mods.
[QUOTE=kimr120;42346201]I don't care if you have different opinions and hate people who are racists or anti-gay. You should not label and ban a person for his phobia or hate as long he is moderately calm, Garry is the only that can ban anyone because their opinion differs from his. This is because he owns the forum.[/QUOTE] There is no free speech on Facepunch, boo hoo garry wants to enforce his rules on his forum, poor oppressed racists If they are really bothered they can just to Stormfront and whinge about it
[QUOTE=Aurora93;42345829]rusty is a p cool dude, check out this video of him in action [media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=M0bY3AVun7I[/media][/QUOTE] I don't remember Rusty looking quite this handsome
My biggest problem with max is that he doesn't hold everyone to the same standard, and he lets personal opinion be basis for bans instead of just forum rules. He'll let his buddies in SH flame all they want but if someone tells them to fuck off, "banned -- flaming"
I think Max is a lot better than he used to be, from what I've seen anyway
Ban all the mods. Let the forum run itself.
_
Remove all of them, and bring back Mikfoz.
[QUOTE=AJisAwesome15;42340089]MaxofS2D[/QUOTE] He has unpopular opinions, sure. But I think he's a pretty fair moderator.
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.