Killing people who commit muder or any serious crimes - IE Dexter the TV show

[Tacosheller]

[QUOTE=Rubs10;32637095]Are you suggesting that you're going to start killing people because freewill doesn't exist?[/QUOTE]

Well if i do it must not be my fault so no punishments

[Boozy&Bitter]

[QUOTE=Tacosheller;32641655]Well if i do it must not be my fault so no punishments[/QUOTE]

It doesn't mean you shouldn't get rehabilitation so you won't do it again.

It isn't your fault, so it's not reasonable to physically harm you or make you "pay a debt" to society.

[cis.joshb]

[QUOTE=Rubs10;32642164]It doesn't mean you shouldn't get rehabilitation so you won't do it again.

It isn't your fault, so it's not reasonable to physically harm you or make you "pay a debt" to society.[/QUOTE]
The brain is like a computer, taking input and output. If jail was only rehabilitation and no punishment (I think it should be partially rehabilitation, but it still needs to have punishment), then the input "if I do bad things I will go to jail which is boring and bad" is removed. This seems like it would drive crime rates up.

[Sillypiggy]

[QUOTE=Contag;32636795]So uh our entire everything system and how we interact goes out the window[/QUOTE] No it doesn't. Its just realizing the world determines how we think and act.

[editline]5th October 2011[/editline]

[QUOTE=Tacosheller;32641655]Well if i do it must not be my fault so no punishments[/QUOTE] I don't see how that changes anything. Either way you shouldn't kill people and either way you should get rehabilitated so you don't do it again.

[Boozy&Bitter]

[QUOTE=cis.joshb;32644566]The brain is like a computer, taking input and output. If jail was only rehabilitation and no punishment (I think it should be partially rehabilitation, but it still needs to have punishment), then the input "if I do bad things I will go to jail which is boring and bad" is removed. This seems like it would drive crime rates up.[/QUOTE]

Rehabilitation is proved to drag crime rates down.

[CoolKingKaso]

I heavily disagree. Not only it makes you them just as barbaric as the murderer, but what if an innocent person was killed due to suspected of committing that crime?

[crackberry]

[QUOTE=GreenDolphin;32620547]An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind.[/QUOTE]

This.

[cis.joshb]

[QUOTE=Rubs10;32647328]Rehabilitation is proved to drag crime rates down.[/QUOTE]
I don't disagree with rehabilitation.

[JaffaOrange]

[QUOTE=cis.joshb;32637056]What is your point? That we should have an eye for an eye system?[/QUOTE]

What? No. My point is that maximum punishment can have an opposite effect when trying to deter crime.

[Radley]

Yes, having everybody going vigilante would kill off everyone pretty quickly.