Forums Discussion v2 - GO TO PAGE 109 FOR SOMETHING NEAT
4,995 replies, posted
[QUOTE=Metaru;52220357]if all mods put you on ignore list, it means you get a free pass to shitpost without supervision?[/QUOTE]
It actually only takes one, but you get restricted to a single board for your shitposting in the process
[QUOTE=Hezzy;52219802]:why:[/QUOTE]
Seems to me like you're the one "QQ'ing" with posts like these:
[QUOTE=Hezzy;52218685]I'm fucking sick of hearing about Tudd
Legitimately going to add his name to the forum word censor if ya'll don't pipe down[/QUOTE]
Did you really expect anything else when you lift Tudd to meme status after April Fools? You pissed on the floor and now you're mad that people are complaining about the piss on the floor.
Also, I do have to say, it's incredibly demeaning and pretentious to reply to actual posts with nonsense like the first quote. Are community managers supposed to be dicks to the community like this?
[QUOTE=ForgottenKane;52220540]Seems to me like you're the one "QQ'ing" with posts like these:
Did you really expect anything else when you lift Tudd to meme status after April Fools? You pissed on the floor and now you're mad that people are complaining about the piss on the floor.
Also, I do have to say, it's incredibly demeaning and pretentious to reply to actual posts with nonsense like the first quote. [B]Are community managers supposed to be dicks to the community like this?[/B][/QUOTE]
Seems par for the course for quite a number of gaming communities, when companies have PR people doing community stuff.
Hezzy should post more funny memes hahaha right guys that woulkd make him a proper GAMER CM.
Like, I usually joke about how craptasket and postal are often the shitposters of the mods, but they give legitimate thought and time to their replies with people when they reply to posts like Zukriuchen's.
I mean, look at this:
[QUOTE=Craptasket;52215974]:thinking: you couldn't bother using forum search?
[url]https://facepunch.com/showthread.php?t=1547740&p=51763764#post51763764[/url]
[url]https://facepunch.com/showthread.php?t=1530010&p=50879014#post50879014[/url]
[url]https://facepunch.com/showthread.php?t=1526792&p=50727868#post50727868[/url]
I mean it's pretty obvious why these people would get banned, do I have to really explain it? We hand these out like candy to people that seem they're about to blow their top and break actual forum rules.
[url]https://facepunch.com/showthread.php?t=1510933&p=49954040#post49954040[/url]
[url]https://facepunch.com/showthread.php?t=1415902&p=45635746#post45635746[/url]
[url]https://facepunch.com/showthread.php?t=1413564&p=45544509#post45544509[/url]
You been here for 7 years and you have no idea why we ban/lock furry topics and posts? I know it's rare ban by now, but It is guaranteed people will derail a thread over furry content, so just retroactively close threads about it or ban people posting it. Even if the judgement call for furry stuff to be removed is lost, it's always consistent furry threads go to shit - became commonsense to me at least.
About "not a LMAO pic" I'm hoping people realize they should be posting things that are funny to others and not just them. That should be how to avoid that ban. No ones being banned solely because a mod thinks the picture is only unfunny. I hope not but I wouldn't blame them, modding LMAO pics sucks. You need to post a specific example or you get the generic "it was probably really unfunny and didn't belong there" answer.
I get it though, none of these are on the rules page and the actual explanation / First judgement ruling on why they're banned in the first place are probably lost somewhere. All these judgement calls are by memory, I'm sorry they're not perfect. being "extremely vague, inconsistently enforced, and wildly open for interpretation" for old/unwritten rules is the best you're going to get on a forum on the internet. None of those bans happen without Mod Discretion which should always has a reasonable explanation baked into it before banning, so just asking us why shouldn't be a problem.
We can ban for taking the piss, trolling, baiting, drama, all of that and more. The problem is you fucks have elevated Tudd meme status so high it has become impossible to tell if hes doing that or not. Tudd really doesn't have to move a centimeter to get people mad, and that is squarely your fault. Mod Discretion doesn't even work here, in fact to ban him now would only be of mob rule / personal.
Since we have a grid lock and it might seem someone is taking advantage of it, only a new rule or judgement call can get that fixed. Restricting a user on where to post isn't the answer either.[/QUOTE]
This shit is respectable, even if I disagree.
[editline]12th May 2017[/editline]
[QUOTE=BlackMageMari;52220555]Seems par for the course for quite a number of gaming communities, when companies have PR people doing community stuff.[/QUOTE]
I mean, many games have bled out their playerbase much faster than they should because of shit community managers. Look at Diablo 3. Goddamn that old CM was fucking [i]awful[/i].
But that doesn't really apply here I think. Facepunch has long since evolved past just a Garry's Mod forum/Rust forum. This is a community I honestly hold dear and while I disagree with a lot of the things the mod team does sometimes, I truly do love them. The mods here (and Garry's lax attitude with the forums) have groomed this place into one of my favorite places on the internet.
Hell, I don't even hate Tudd. I just think his threads suck and that his "meme status" is getting out of hand. I legitimately thought it was funny for a while and the April Fools day charade was pretty great, but it's evolved past that at this point.
Letting Tudd freely shitpost and bait people is not the way to make this forum less biased Hezzy.
[QUOTE=ForgottenKane;52220540]Are community managers supposed to be dicks to the community like this?[/QUOTE]
welcome to facepunch enjoy your stay
imo tuddposting has gotten so incessant i find it way more annoying than the occasional shit thread
maybe i'm biased because i have his signature in my event log
Long time lurker here, just wanted to throw in my 2 cents on the quality of tudd's threads:
[t]https://i.imgur.com/N8NxLZA.png[/t]
[QUOTE=Damjen;52220703]Letting Tudd freely shitpost and bait people is not the way to make this forum less biased Hezzy.[/QUOTE]
That only creates more friction and hateposting due to special treatment.
[QUOTE=Mort Stroodle;52220756]welcome to facepunch enjoy your stay[/QUOTE]
I didn't even realize we had one until recently when I saw Hezzy's title. Are community managers here actually just mascots? Like TH89 or [i]a certain frenchman hon hon[/i] at the peak of their absurd modding?
[QUOTE=Van-man;52220862]That only creates more friction and hateposting due to special treatment.[/QUOTE]
which in turn causes more complaining
like im not even talking about the april fools thing, that was fine, but shitposting every time someone complains about tudd is just going to cause more complaining lol
Make Tudd have a normal avatar/title.
Let people call him out in threads he makes/posts
Maintain banning people who call him (or anyone else) out in threads he isn't even involved with.
Let Tudd continue posting whatever he wants as long as it conforms with the usual rules (not late, not editorialized title, etc)
If you still can't stand Tudd just add him to your ignore list. The ignore list sucks but it's not getting fixed any time soon. Don't click his threads.
put me in the mod team coach I'm ready.
[QUOTE=McCoolName;52220852]Long time lurker here, just wanted to throw in my 2 cents on the quality of tudd's threads:
[t]https://i.imgur.com/N8NxLZA.png[/t][/QUOTE]
Image macros are allowed if they're OC, you don't need a gimmick account.
[QUOTE=Mort Stroodle;52220026]Have we bannned reagy for furry shit yet?[/QUOTE]
Fucking excuse me?
Also, I've been meaning to ask this for a while, [i]where the fuck is Dav0r[/i]? I haven't seen him in a while.
I remember when he was a normal member and literally one of the worst posters on the entire forums by a long shot. He made Tudd (or rather what many people make Tudd out to be) look like a fucking baby. Then one day he was modded and I felt like the world went upside down, the forums were going to go on fire, tyranny was about to descend on mankind.
Then he became a great poster. What kind of Mike Pence shock therapy did you guys use on him? Jesus Christ he made the switch so fast I thought I switched universes or something. I miss him now.
[QUOTE=Raidyr;52220890]Let people call him out in threads he makes/posts[/QUOTE]
I think that all we really need is further elaboration on what a fair callout is.
If it's just "oh look another tudd thread" then that contributes nothing.
If it's a "oh look another tudd thread" followed by a relatively lengthy explanation as to why the story and source is a crock of shit then that should be allowed.
[QUOTE=ForgottenKane;52220914]Also, I've been meaning to ask this for a while, [i]where the fuck is Dav0r[/i]? I haven't seen him in a while.
I remember when he was a normal member and literally one of the worst posters on the entire forums by a long shot. He made Tudd (or rather what many people make Tudd out to be) look like a fucking baby. Then one day he was modded and I felt like the world went upside down, the forums were going to go on fire, tyranny was about to descend on mankind.
Then he became a great poster. What kind of Mike Pence shock therapy did you guys use on him? Jesus Christ he made the switch so fast I thought I switched universes or something. I miss him now.[/QUOTE]
We gave him alcohol.
[QUOTE=Reagy;52220908]Fucking excuse me?[/QUOTE]
more like fucking cats judging by these avatars of yours am I right ladies and germs
I'm calling for a special prosecutor to look into Tudd's ties to shitposting as I don't believe the current partisan committee in charge can be trusted
[QUOTE=Mort Stroodle;52220924]more like fucking cats judging by these avatars of yours am I right ladies and germs[/QUOTE]
Now that's just damn rude and wrong.
I should slap you for that but that'd also be wrong.
[QUOTE=Mort Stroodle;52220924]more like fucking cats judging by these avatars of yours am I right ladies and germs[/QUOTE]
it's a dog
dogfucker war round 2
[QUOTE=Kiwi;52220972]Owned[/QUOTE]
Shut it weeb.
mommy and daddy are fighting again
[QUOTE=Kiwi;52220991]OK hell hound fucker[/QUOTE]
Wait, I thought it worked the other way round??
[QUOTE=ForgottenKane;52220914]Also, I've been meaning to ask this for a while, [i]where the fuck is Dav0r[/i]? I haven't seen him in a while.
I remember when he was a normal member and literally one of the worst posters on the entire forums by a long shot. He made Tudd (or rather what many people make Tudd out to be) look like a fucking baby. Then one day he was modded and I felt like the world went upside down, the forums were going to go on fire, tyranny was about to descend on mankind.
Then he became a great poster. What kind of Mike Pence shock therapy did you guys use on him? Jesus Christ he made the switch so fast I thought I switched universes or something. I miss him now.[/QUOTE]
Holy fuck yes.
Tudd Actual Mod 2017.
Make me mod and I will never start a thread again.
[QUOTE=Tudd;52221021]Holy fuck yes.
Tudd Actual Mod 2017.
Make me mod and I will never start a thread again.[/QUOTE]
I will only support this if criticizing Trump becomes bannable again.
[QUOTE=ForgottenKane;52220914]Also, I've been meaning to ask this for a while, [i]where the fuck is Dav0r[/i]? I haven't seen him in a while.
I remember when he was a normal member and literally one of the worst posters on the entire forums by a long shot. He made Tudd (or rather what many people make Tudd out to be) look like a fucking baby. Then one day he was modded and I felt like the world went upside down, the forums were going to go on fire, tyranny was about to descend on mankind.
Then he became a great poster. What kind of Mike Pence shock therapy did you guys use on him? Jesus Christ he made the switch so fast I thought I switched universes or something. I miss him now.[/QUOTE]
he is living a good life according to his facebook
let him rest in peace
[editline]12th May 2017[/editline]
[QUOTE=Tudd;52221021]Holy fuck yes.
Tudd Actual Mod 2017.
Make me mod and I will never start a thread again.[/QUOTE]
there you have it, the best possible outcome and everyone is left satisfied
[QUOTE=Damjen;52220703]Letting Tudd freely shitpost and bait people is not the way to make this forum less biased Hezzy.[/QUOTE]
we should ban tudd and then build a wall around facepunch so no more tudds can get in
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.