I'm facing a legal / emotional dilemma, need some perspective - General

[QUOTE=Egevened;17944291]Since I know your posts and think you are pretty intelligent, what are your reasons for going A? The guy himself probably could face a charge.[/QUOTE] Yes he would risk a charge, but after all I think the police will have some kind of understanding in the situation. Seeing as his brother brought his son, that might be one of the explanations on why he didn't call the cop earlier, and that it actually is his brother. He could also say that he was unknowing that his brother was hiding from the police etc...

[QUOTE=Mr_Proudfoot;17944414]Why are you getting so butthurt over someone mentioning hitler? He was a psychopath.[/QUOTE] It's the worst argument that anyone can bring up when someone does something bad.

[QUOTE=Conn92;17944422]When he was a child...[/QUOTE] You can't really blame him.. imo he's mentally fucked up. [editline]04:45PM[/editline] [QUOTE=Egevened;17944436]It's the worst argument that anyone can bring up when someone does something bad.[/QUOTE] come out of the closet you neo-nazi

[QUOTE=Swebonny;17944426]Yes he would risk a charge, but after all I think the police will have some kind of understanding in the situation. Seeing as his brother brought his son, that might be one of the explanations on why he didn't call the cop earlier, and that it actually is his brother. He could also say that he was unknowing that his brother was hiding from the police etc...[/QUOTE] The problem with your logic here is that his brother is a breathing and thinking person, and he probably will speak if he can. Sure I understand what you are trying to say here and I mostly agree with your idea, but the bad thing about this is that law can be bent in many ways, especially with these cases. [editline]04:46PM[/editline] [QUOTE=Mr_Proudfoot;17944438] come out of the closet you neo-nazi[/QUOTE] Oh it's my avatar, isn't it. Someone hasn't watched the movie to the end.

[QUOTE=Egevened;17944452]The problem with your logic here is that his brother is a breathing and thinking person, and he probably will speak if he can. Sure I understand what you are trying to say here and I mostly agree with your idea, but the bad thing about this is that law can be bent in many ways, especially with these cases. [/QUOTE] All the criminals in the jails, mass murderers, pedophiles and rapists are breathing and thinking persons. [editline]04:50PM[/editline] I don't believe there should be a third or a fourth chance.

The breathing and thinking was referencing his capability to comunicate If he has a chance, he'll talk

I'm still gonna have to go with A. It sounds like he's had enough chances, and he's bringing you into it by hiding in your home.

[QUOTE=Egevened;17944452]The problem with your logic here is that his brother is a breathing and thinking person, and he probably will speak if he can. Sure I understand what you are trying to say here and I mostly agree with your idea, but the bad thing about this is that law can be bent in many ways, especially with these cases. [editline]04:46PM[/editline] Oh it's my avatar, isn't it. Someone hasn't watched the movie to the end.[/QUOTE] the only part i watched was the end. funny isn't it.

[QUOTE=J Paul;17943228]I've been thinking about it, and now I have the idea that he might possibly try to kill me again if I turn him in. I'm already well aware that he is most definitely not willing to cooperate with the authorities. When they raided his house to try to arrest him, they rolled in deep on him. Multiple squad cars, and probably some dogs. He escaped capture by jumping out of a second story window and hiding in the woods, in a creek, for four hours in nothing but pajama pants. In this incredibly cold weather, I consider a feat like that to be almost super-human. Also, considering the things he has done in the past, which are of a much grander scale than even that, I'm convinced that he probably is super-human. He's never lost a fight as far as I'm aware, and I don't think he ever will. He could probably kill anyone he meets with his bare hands. In addition to his physical prowess, he is also incredibly intelligent. He also happens to be a sociopath. Given that he has already attempted murder against me once for no reason at all, there is a chance that he would do it again in retaliation for my snitching, and most likely succeed this time. I'm not completely convinced that this is the case, but the possibility can't be ignored.[/QUOTE] 9mm rounds are the god levellers, they bring everyone down to the same basic meaty foundations. So if tries anything shoot him. Brothers shouldn't try to kill each other, he broke the fucking blood bond, time for you to end it i suppose.

Fucking A.

I am curious how old are you and your brother I would Suggest A, Even though he is your brother, he never done anything good for you but instead more trouble. Fuck him Up Big Time.

When in doubt, go with C. If it were me, I wouldn't let family ties get in the way. He's still another human being, and he made the choice to fuck you over.

[QUOTE=Egevened;17944532]The breathing and thinking was referencing his capability to comunicate If he has a chance, he'll talk[/QUOTE] Oh sorry misunderstood your line there. I still think it might be hard for him to voluntary go and speak with the police. By the description he seems like a very untrustworthy person and generally a bad person that won't change the way he acts. Maybe he'll soften up if he call the police and they threat to take his son from him...

A detective like you should know fff

Turn him in, not for bitter reasons. You're doing it to cover your own ass. Say it wasn't you and that you suspect it to be your brother, who you're afraid will attempt to harm you again (mention the murder attempt). The cops won't take it lightly, they'll send a car around your house, most likely plain-clothes. This isn't a "fuck your brother" situation, this is a situation where you're getting out of false charges and you had better not lie to the cops. Plus, if they catch him, using false identification with the cops is a federal offense. I think 7 years is the standard jailtime, which would be buffed up considering he's got a kid (endangering a minor) and he's avoided the police for so long. If caught, by the time he got out you'd have time to get the fuck away from him.

I'd say don't try and have a talk with him - he might try to "silence" you. If you threaten him with going to the police, you're in more danger than just going to the police. [QUOTE=wildturkey50;17944335]A. Hes a fucking faggot.[/QUOTE] I don't think he is; he seems to have had sex with a woman at some point in order to have conceived a child.

[QUOTE=Splurgy;17944911]I don't think he is; he seems to have had sex with a woman at some point in order to have conceived a child.[/QUOTE] you dont know if he liked it or not :smug:

How many years in jail? If not too many I'd go with B

Choose Option A. While he's in jail train and lift weights like hell. so you can beat the crap out of him if he tries something when he comes out... (or buy a Gun)

dont be a cunt and snitch on your family. if you do, i hope bad thing happen to you

C)Fuck him. Also inform the police of his current whereabouts. Nobody deserves the shit he's putting you through. Your father is a bad person for supporting someone who is such an obvious asshole. The only way your brother is going to get better is if he does hard time and then seriously tries to turn his life around. He should try to clear his record and then join the Army. They might be able to straighten him out.

By letting him get away with it you are opening yourself to him using you for your entire life. He stole your identity, imagine how that will affect your future if you don't get your name cleared. Besides, even if you do get your name cleared he'll just do it again. [QUOTE=J Paul;17943612]All things considered, he actually is a good father. He's not a good person, but he's done a good job with my nephew so far.[/QUOTE] A father is a role model to a son, your nephew will be deeply affected by his behaviour. Anyone who puts their family over and over again in legal (or otherwise) danger to protect themselves cannot be a good father... Also, if you let him get away with it he's out there to terrorise everyone else.

I'd go with option A, it's the only way he's going to learn what he is doing is wrong.

And I thought my family had a fuckup or two. Damn you seem to have had a bad time thanks to him, and with him using your identity to cover for a crime he will have ruined your chances to get a decent job, clear your name, turn that asshole in, and inform the PolIce that he has violent tendancies. They should be able to deal with it. If anything, do it to make sure you have a criminal record free future, records will destroy you sometimes. Yeah I have a feeling I am very late, but fuck trying to read through a thread on a mobile with barely any charge left.

A. He tried to kill you man...

OP, option A, your brother is a fuckup, a backstabber, and an asshole, he does no good for you, for others, or the world. It's people like him that make me rage, that make me wish the entire human race didn't exist. Fuck him, send the fucker into prison, where I hope he gets raped. [QUOTE=Goatham;17945484]dont be a cunt and snitch on your family. if you do, i hope bad thing happen to you[/QUOTE] Dumb, dumb, dumb, [url=http://www.facepunch.com/showpost.php?p=17945484&postcount=141]give this man boxes.[/url]

You guys seem to think that his brother is some kind of psychotic maniac that run around beating people up. Oh, he tried strangling his little brother when he was like what 11? You do not see the consequences as a child and I bet you've done some kind of felony in your youth, I know I have. Let him run, he's family and his bond to you goes deeper than to be cut by a couple of things like him using your identity. Let him run, he has a son but tell him to leave you alone in the future or else you will report him. Would you actually send your brother to jail for giving you a minor nuisance with the law that probably could be easily solved? I know I would not :v:

Your credit is at stake, and if that goes on your record you may not be able to go to college if you want, or possibly a job. So A) Fuck Him :cop:

C) but ask if there is a reward first, then tell them, if not, tell them anyway, but be not so happy that you didn't get paid.

A: Bastard sounds like a tool, also try to get his kid put in protective custody.