Should we allow the weird porn threads (IE: "What turns you on" type threads with furry/vore/beastia

[Shier]

[QUOTE=toastedjam;46261362]I don't mind seeing a few NSFW posts of topless girls and whatnot, but i don't want to see hardcore porn or people's weird fetishes that's over the top hardcore. It's pretty gross.[/QUOTE]

And that's something I don't like about this whole thing.
This hipocrisy about porn.
"Your porn is bad, mine's okay, ban yours, keep mine."
While banning the worst is nice step towards the better, I think the best would just banning ALL the porn.
My opinion though, not gonna force it to anyone.

[Muntu]

[QUOTE=bitches;46261435]Total double standard. Is someone forcing you to view these threads?[/QUOTE]

why does this fucking argument keep coming up

i already wrote a story about why it's so bad

[bepassley]

It keeps going back to this simple fact: There isn't a single reason why this forum should host any kind of porn threads. A)Not every user is an adult and more importantly, B) It breeds an environment in which people start posting more and more fucked up things over the course of time (example: the situation now).

If you REALLY, REALLY think you NEED a place to post about what you just jerked off to today.. please seek help and/or do it somewhere besides facepunch. That is all, thanks.

[Dr. Gestapo]

just ban everything, no compromise. you can set up a chatroom while you share gross stuff if that's why the thread appeals to you.

no one should be forced to babysit you just so you can keep sharing weird fetish shit.

[Kirbyfactor]

get rid of 'em

[Kidd]

If you want a thread to discuss fetishes is that impossible to do without image dumping hardcore animals banging each other with saliva dripping from their lips?

[Tools]

I don't get why we don't just move the WTYO to the OIFY so it's not in plain view for those who don't want to see it's content.

Boom, problem solved?

[Shier]

[QUOTE=Tools;46261565]I don't get why we don't just move the WTYO to the OIFY so it's not in plain view for those who don't want to see it's content.

Boom, problem solved?[/QUOTE]

It's more of that some of us thinks that stuff like that shouldn't on this site. Like AT ALL.
Not just hidden away somewhere.

[Bridger]

I honestly forgot the porn threads even existed :v:

I remember the first time I checked them out my first thought was "Man, I really feel bad for the mods who have to keep this shit in line"

I'm fairly neutral about this, I won't be going to them if they stay and I won't miss them if they're gone.

[Tools]

[QUOTE=Dom Pyroshark;46261587]It's more of that some of us thinks that stuff like that shouldn't on this site. Like AT ALL.
Not just hidden away somewhere.[/QUOTE]

Last time I visited the OIFY there were armies of bots linking obscure underground porn there on a daily basis, not to mention the "I'll put ___ in my ___ if this topic hits ___ posts" threads.
Surely they won't mind a little extra furry/vore/robo t-rex porn.

[Frugle]

I feel like there is no clear line what is "weird porn" and what isn't. Therefore they should be allowed OR ban all threads with nudity.

[DokVis]

Fuck it, move it to OIFY, everyone would be happy since no one in their right mind goes to OIFY, well expect Craptasket. You can't say that would effect the image of the board, most people seem not to know/care about it.

That or just remove porn, and OIFY. since you know, it will still show up on OIFY, as its a shithole.

[ClarkWasHere]

[QUOTE]Can my vote be voided please?[/QUOTE]

[Ownederd]

[QUOTE=Thomo_UK;46259901]If it leaves my catgirls alone, close the porn threads and change mine to no.[/QUOTE]

is that thread the only highlight of your day or something

[ForNoReason]

I don't even see what the problem with the catgirl thread could be. It's pretty damn tame and they keep to themselves

[EIREXE]

Allow it as long as it doesn't leak over to other threads.

Like, if you don't want it don't go in the thread, but forbit it elsewhere.

[zerothefallen]

[QUOTE=For No Reason;46261995]I don't even see what the problem with the catgirl thread could be. It's pretty damn tame and they keep to themselves[/QUOTE]

its like not sexual

... about 50% of the time

[ForNoReason]

[QUOTE=Yahnich;46262167]solution:

ban all nsfw images; allow the wtyo thread to exist (pictureless considering fetish pics can basically never be sfw meaning it's actually just discussing kinks and probably will die by itself after a day)

this will result in the hot girls and hot guys thread to actually only be about hot girls and hot guys (who would be fully clothed), catgirl thread can continue sharing their catgirl images as long as they're not nsfw etc etc

everyone wins[/QUOTE]

not a bad plan tbh

[Doom14]

[QUOTE=Yahnich;46262167]solution:[/QUOTE]

I'd vote for it.

[Snickerdoodle]

[QUOTE=Yahnich;46262167]solution:

ban all nsfw images; allow the wtyo thread to exist (pictureless considering fetish pics can basically never be sfw meaning it's actually just discussing kinks and probably will die by itself after a day)

this will result in the hot girls and hot guys thread to actually only be about hot girls and hot guys (who would be fully clothed), catgirl thread can continue sharing their catgirl images as long as they're not nsfw etc etc

everyone wins[/QUOTE]

I like this idea.

[MuThing]

whatever it takes i just want the dogfucker pictures gone

[Muntu]

[QUOTE=Yahnich;46262167]solution:

ban all nsfw images; allow the wtyo thread to exist (pictureless considering fetish pics can basically never be sfw meaning it's actually just discussing kinks and probably will die by itself after a day)

this will result in the hot girls and hot guys thread to actually only be about hot girls and hot guys (who would be fully clothed), catgirl thread can continue sharing their catgirl images as long as they're not nsfw etc etc

everyone wins[/QUOTE]

i kind of want to see this happen

the main argument the (utterly filthy) yes side had was "we like to talk about our fetishes"

i want to see how long they'll keep it up without being able to post pics or even links if possible

[ForNoReason]

[QUOTE=MasterFen006;46262224]whatever it takes i just want the dogfucker pictures gone[/QUOTE]

Don't start this shit again.

[Zonesylvania]

[QUOTE=MasterFen006;46262224]whatever it takes i just want the dogfucker pictures gone[/QUOTE]
[t]http://n3cdn.co.uk/wp-content/uploads/2013/04/Broken_record2.jpg[/t]

[chezhead]

I personally wouldn't have a problem with a pornography subforum, but others might not like how that impacts the image of Facepunch as a whole.

[Massaki]

While you're at it, remove the creepy 'would you fuck the above user's avatar' 'x's avatar is I'm bed with you' threads. They're also fucking embarrassing.

[ROFLBURGER]

[QUOTE=Doom14;46260777]I hate to rewind, but you'd be a bit fucking naffed if you actually think they're an exaggeration. Maybe not to that extreme, but FA's literally a giant creepy circle jerk of dicksucking and self-dicksucking in the comments.

No different than E621, sans the occasional humorous comment. No different than Redtube and xHamster. No different than Youtube.

Whether it's the users or it's a relic from the Smartness Era, Facepunch has some (mild, not really) quality control and it's probably the reason I still love this place so much. Because I can actively read threads without horrible grammar, spammed similes, image macros, and other dumb shit.
[/QUOTE]

I think you're forgetting I made that video.
It was a bitch getting comments that are creepy enough, I spent more time on there than I expected. Those comments represent 5-10% of FA which made me say "what the fuck these people are having normal discussions"

FA is literrally the same thing as that thread. No reason to go there for your porn.

[Rixxz2]

[QUOTE=Frugle;46261942]I feel like there is no clear line what is "weird porn" and what isn't. Therefore they should be allowed OR ban all threads with nudity.[/QUOTE]

That's the way I feel, as well.
Some people seem inclined to remove certain threads not because they contain things that are actually illegal in most places, or other such completely logical reasons, but because "I think it's gross and people should stop liking what I don't like.

pls keep the porn threads i like becaus i think its really secksi tho"

It just turns the decision from actually being rational, to being really childish and stupid in my opinion.

Realize that whatever it is that you're attracted to, this is not the place to discuss it.* [U]No matter what it is[/U].

*= I see absolutely no problem with having for example a gay, the "Sex & Girlfriends chat thread" and a furry thread, just don't use them as some kind of porn deposit

[HybridTheroy]

[QUOTE=Arc Nova;46244215]if you think about fucking 8 year olds its ok[/QUOTE]

arc nova what would ur mother say

[Doom14]

[QUOTE=ROFLBURGER;46262586]FA is literrally the same thing as that thread. No reason to go there for your porn.[/QUOTE]

I can't take the time to prove you wrong about that, because FA is down. :v:

I'm not going to argue that you did cherrypick extremes, but the conversations on FA are a far shot from even WTYO at it's worst. Please, take it from a faggot who actually goes to FA frequently over you going there to make a video mocking them. I can't explain the irony in someone, having made a parody video of a group they don't go to, defending the the same group while someone who's actively seen said group far longer tries to counter.

Let me try this again:

This
[t]http://40.media.tumblr.com/324609b724864cc456dc757fd154492c/tumblr_my1ivd4vob1r57kuio1_1280.png[/t]

Is
[t]http://i49.tinypic.com/cjfvc.jpg[/t]

Normal
[t]http://40.media.tumblr.com/557cdc444bfb17108a86acc0af480ed6/tumblr_ml9g12SRzL1r95kb8o1_500.png[/t]

There
[t]http://41.media.tumblr.com/1eed6aa6e36ee4b000707e716a75c94b/tumblr_ml9fnosGjA1r95kb8o1_500.png[/t]

Meanwhile, WTYO, random backtracked page, here's a sample conversation

[quote]Are you going to start a philosophical debate over every single image?

Personally when I go "hey, that's kinda hot", I don't have any deep reasoning behind it. Especially for anthro stuff like elites/furries/sharkgirls/catgirls/etc, which are basically humans with slight modifications. [/quote]
[quote]Well maybe it helps to understand why you like certain things to better understand yourself? Really helps to think with your HEAD sometimes, not just your dick. [/quote]
[quote]I think I speak for everyone with an interest in something quirky when I say, "I ain't gotta 'splain shit" [/quote]

Granted, this whole spiel is still pretty moot because we could both sit down and cherrypick either side to be bastions of conversation or insanity. I'm just saying FA isn't a place for normal conversations. Maybe their forums are better? Maybe not. It's kind of apples to oranges, really. I'm just falling back on the whole "Find WYTO a nice, similar place to do the same, and they'd pack up and leave" concept.