[QUOTE=Denzo;20308410]I really hate how they just cut away the whole part with Tom Bombadil in the first movie.[/QUOTE]
I think they probably cut it simply because of the on going debate about what Tom Bombadil is, it can be really confusing
[editline]25th September 2011[/editline]
[QUOTE=matark;20318934]I recently rewatched the whole extended series for the first time in years. And now that I'm older, I'm seeing a lot of plot holes in the movies. While still really good movies, some stuff just broke my suspension of disbelief. Such as when the Witch King [sp]corners Gandalf at Minas Tirith but he hears the Rohirrim about to flank Mordor's army. Why doesn't he just kill Gandalf? Is it really that imperative to fight off the Rohirrim that he couldn't take two seconds to kill [I]the leader of the enemy army[/I]. [/sp]
Another point is when Legolas [sp] informs Aragorn about the Army of the Dead, which is ostensibly an immortal and invulnerable army who Aragorn can command pretty much at will. Why doesn't Legolas say something at Helms Deep? You would think that it would cross his mind to say, "Oh hey, by the way there's an invincible army you can command that no mortal weapon can even fight against, just thought that might be useful when we're outnumbered 10:1." [/sp]
And how [sp]Sauron gets tricked into emptying his entire base to defeat Aragorn at the Black Gates.[/sp] You would think that Sauron would leave a few guards near Mt. Doom considering that half of his army is more than enough to crush the entire army handily. This oversight is compounded by the fact that Sauron is played off as a master of subterfuge and trickery in the Silmarillion. Why didn't he see this coming? Did he really think the king of Men, who lead his army to two incredible military victories in the past few months would really do something so stupid?[/QUOTE]
I don't know if you don't realise it but not all of this is Peter Jackson's doing, they're not plot holes in the movie if he was simply following what Tolkien had originally written as to not let down the fans of the lord of the rings
Just about 2 weeks ago I saw all three movies in the largest cinema in Denmark. Pretty. Damn. Fucking. Awesome. But damn was I tired, it was a friday so I was up from about 6:40 and it began 23:59, and ended 10:40.
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.