Why not to send people to labour camps instead of executing them? - General

You raped my sister and murdered my family, I'm watching you fucking burn.

[QUOTE=Novistador;24571542]I like how someone with the name freethinker has just come up with the idea of gulags.[/QUOTE] Sure, why not? It would make more benefit to the society than executing people.

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571510]Of course they would take your job away - they could work 12 hours every day and don't get paid, doing more benefit to the society than you.[/QUOTE] There would probably be a point where they would rather die than be forced to work, and either make you kill them or commit suicide themselves. So, to keep them from wanting to die you give them incentive to keep living (resources). So you are wasting time with them anyways. :colbert:

This thread has ridiculously massive miscommunication.

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571553]Sure, why not? It would make more benefit to the society than executing people.[/QUOTE] Because all forced labor is wrong. If its voluntary then I don't care if they work their ass off.

[QUOTE=L'ordinateur;24571569]There would probably be a point where they would rather die than be forced to work, and either make you kill them or commit suicide themselves. So, to keep them from wanting to die you give them resources. So you are wasting time with them anyways. :colbert:[/QUOTE] It doesn't change the fact that the labour produced by them would cover the cost of the camps and make additional profit.

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571553]Sure, why not? It would make more benefit to the society than executing people.[/QUOTE] You can eat them and take their powers. [editline]01:39PM[/editline] so no

[QUOTE=OvB;24571578]Because all forced labor is wrong. If its voluntary then I don't care if they work their ass off.[/QUOTE] And forced execution isn't wrong, rite? :downs: Except in the case of labour camps, they would make profit.

[QUOTE=OvB;24571578]Because all forced labor is wrong. If its voluntary then I don't care if they work their ass off.[/QUOTE] but yet being forced to die is not?

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571605]It doesn't change the fact that the labour produced by them would cover the cost of the camps and make additional profit.[/QUOTE] Depends on how much they actually produce to how much they consume.

[QUOTE=L'ordinateur;24571638]Depends on how much they actually produce to how much they consume.[/QUOTE] The production would be much higher due to the fact that they would be forced to work.

[QUOTE=OvB;24571434]Because forcing people to work is cruel and unusual punishment.[/QUOTE] Exactly. Eighth Amendment prevents this from happening in the US.

Freethinker doesn't do much thinking. [QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571655]The production would be much higher due to the fact that they would be forced to work.[/QUOTE] That's called slavery/indentured servitude. We outlawed that a hundred years ago.

[QUOTE=yuki;24571661]Freethinker doesn't do much thinking.[/QUOTE] How exactly?

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571621]And forced execution isn't wrong, rite? :downs: Except in the case of labour camps, they would make profit.[/QUOTE] 1. Force someone to work until they kill themselves or die from over exhaustion and abuse. 2.Kill someone in a few minutes using lethal injection. Yours sounds more sick, fucked up, and inhumane to me. I'd rather die than be forced to work.

[QUOTE=yuki;24571661]Freethinker doesn't do much thinking. That's called slavery.[/QUOTE] Slavery would make profit unlike forced execution. Rated box.

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571655]The production would be much higher due to the fact that they would be forced to work.[/QUOTE] And then they kill themselves :colbert:

[QUOTE=OvB;24571668]1. Force someone to work until they kill themselves or die from over exhaustion and abuse. 2.Kill someone in a few minutes using lethal injection. Yours sounds more sick, fucked up, and inhumane to me. I'd rather die than be forced to work.[/QUOTE] You forgot to mention that the first one does a lot of benefit to the society.

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571510]Of course they would take your job away - they could work 12 hours every day and don't get paid, doing more benefit to the society than you.[/QUOTE] If that is the case then the economy would drop like a rock. You get money to spend money to help the economy.

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571676]Slavery would make profit unlike forced execution. Rated box.[/QUOTE] uh what

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571676]Slavery would make profit unlike forced execution. Rated box.[/QUOTE] Your point? We had this neat thing called the "Civil War" over the concept of slavery. We concluded it was unjust and outlawed it after beating the shit out of the southern states. You can't force someone to work, it's simply not ethically correct.

[QUOTE=L'ordinateur;24571688]And then they kill themselves :colbert:[/QUOTE] And profit would still be made

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571676]Slavery would make profit unlike forced execution. Rated box.[/QUOTE] ...

[QUOTE=Nerdy;24571448]No because then they take jobs away from people who actually need them. Like me.[/QUOTE] Make them do the jobs that nobody wants to do. Also make it a choice.

[QUOTE=yuki;24571694]Your point? We had this neat thing called the "Civil War" over the concept of slavery. We concluded it was unjust and outlawed it after beating the shit out of the southern states.[/QUOTE] Who cares what some dumb men did a long time ago?

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571676]Slavery would make profit unlike forced execution. Rated box.[/QUOTE] Have fun trying to tame a bunch of murders and other criminals to work for you.

[QUOTE=Silly Sil;24571500]You could harvest them for spare body parts and transplants.[/QUOTE] This definately Don't they already do this?

[QUOTE=OvB;24571709]Have fun trying to tame a bunch of murders and other criminals to work for you.[/QUOTE] Actually, most of them worked in Gulags.

[QUOTE=Extroll;24571705]Make them do the jobs that nobody wants to do.[/QUOTE] We already have people who do that here in the US. :v:

[QUOTE=FreeThinker;24571690]You forgot to mention that the first one does a lot of benefit to the society.[/QUOTE] Who care's that we abuse human rights by having negroes pick our cotton! It's benefiting society!