PGunnii - Toy Story - General

I only watched this one and the crash one. I can see what people mean when they say you act like they're the best thing ever but tbh, I kinda like how you do that. Its fun sitting down and listening to you break down everything and seem so enthusiastic about it. Keep it up!

[QUOTE=Mort Stroodle;48225715]Yeah, a lot of these seem really, really heavy-handed with the "this is the best thing in existence" thing. Like, I get that it's hyperbole, but you seem to be overdoing it a bit.[/QUOTE] But he's right though. [editline]17th July 2015[/editline] Also, this was fucking amazing. I loved it. Liked, favorited, subbed, sent to twitter and facebook. You deserve more attention, man.

I really like your style, and your videos are entertaining as heck, but by the end of the video you had spoken a lot without really saying anything about the film. It felt like a good chunk was just going over what was happening in the film step by step and making remarks about what just happened. It was almost like an entertaining, condensed running commentary of the film at points. There were a few bits obviously where you talk about the cinematography of some bits and why some bits were good, but for such a long video it was kind of exhausting to hear you enthusiastically retell a film I've seen over and over. It was good tho

Yeah I really can't get past the whole "best thing everrr" thing. It reminds me of James Rolfe when he's talking about things he likes except there's a bigger impact in that case since his schtick is on the other end of the spectrum, calling 90% of what he reviews the worst thing he's ever seen. Killuah's right, you have a really great enthusiastic vibe and you're funny (though most of the jokes lack a bit of punch imo), but I'd probably like these videos more if they were toned down a bit. And to go with what Killuah and some others said, giving more reasons as to why something is so groundbreaking and great would be good, because you're so much into all of this that I can't tell if you like it "just because" (nostalgia due to it being a big part of your childhood) or if you understand clearly what makes it all good.

i'm more of a movie guy than a game guy, so i only watched the toy story one, but damn. you pretty much made the best style of review one can. you didn't seem like a tryhard (most of doug walker's stuff), you didn't overdo the editing (the punchlines weren't all loud noises that are cut off early), and you made watching the summary of a movie i've seen a million times just as emotional as it is to watch it in full - possibly more so than if i were to watch it without your commentary because you brought to light aspects of the movie that i never consciously realized. if you like doing this, keep doing it, because you do it really well. edit: also i criticize the shit out of [I]everything[/I] i see. even things i like, i let loose on in uncensored criticism. the only thing i can say that i didn't like about that video is that sometimes your voice cracks and it sounds too high or screechy. but that's just your voice probably, and not nostalgia critic-style over-emphasis. also i just noticed that they modeled the texture on the bottom of the vans that sid has. that's some attention to detail. his teeth probably have the highest polycount of anything else in the movie though.

[QUOTE=TheFilmSlacker;48228581]There was a bit more of showing the plot near the end, but seriously, have you ever heard someone give this much of an in-depth look at Toy Story? I think this video is pretty much as far as you need to go for the first movie. I'd love to see your thoughts on the two sequels. The second one is probably the most important film for Woody in the trilogy.[/QUOTE] I thought the whole video was essentially a retelling of the films story, with thoughts on what's happening at that points spread over throughout. For this reason, I don't really think this is an "analysis". For the most part it's not analysing anything about the film, just talking about the events. The only review aspect is in the last few minutes. This is fine tho, the video was entertaining as all heck. I just personally like long winded in-depth analysis to films and games, like RLM and MatthewMatosis so that's what I compare this kind of thing to. Like I said tho, the video was still entertaining as heck and I look forward to seeing more.

I really don't want to sound like it's bad or something it's awesome but I'm a cynical bastard and I'd just like to hear more informative stuff and a bit of critique too for good measure. Some points I'd touch with toystory are the obvious pandering to merch and the somewhat simplistic character arch, plot and morale that's basically "all is good if you can fix it in the end" which is not a good morale to teach children IMO but is very prevalent in modern cartoons. Of course the last one was not the point of Toy Story, it's point is the ride, the novelty and all but I think it needs to be mentioned.

[QUOTE=woolio1;48227059]You're doing a great job. Kind of reminds me of Jontron, when Jontron did good videos. Or videos. Or things in general. Anyway, keep it up. You're really killing it.[/QUOTE] He''s like the perfect blend between JonTron and YourMovieSucksDOTorg

My one major complaint is your microphone/sound balancing/whatever it is. You're voice is totally bearable that's not it at all, but it sounds like a lot of your "ss, sh" etc - are all peaking/low quality. I'm not sure as to what would fix it (pop filter, better mixing, better mic, etc.) Other than that, it was quite an enjoyable watch. I also agree, a bit too much hyperbole, but it didn't turn me off from it at all.

[QUOTE=Killuah;48229587]I really don't want to sound like it's bad or something it's awesome but I'm a cynical bastard and I'd just like to hear more informative stuff and a bit of critique too for good measure. Some points I'd touch with toystory are the obvious pandering to merch and the somewhat simplistic character arch, plot and morale that's basically "all is good if you can fix it in the end" which is not a good morale to teach children IMO but is very prevalent in modern cartoons. Of course the last one was not the point of Toy Story, it's point is the ride, the novelty and all but I think it needs to be mentioned.[/QUOTE] Gotta disagree with you there but Toy Story was all about that character development, meaning, allegories and symbolism. That's what made older kid's movies and shows so good, they were written with typical writing techniques in mind, there's always meaning behind the words, the writers are always evoking an emotional reaction that all ages can relate to. Whereas modern kid's movies and shows are pretty much completely two dimensional, which is why movies like Toy Story will go down in history as 'literal magic in the form of a film reel'.

[QUOTE=Rossy167;48244092]Gotta disagree with you there but Toy Story was all about that character development, meaning, allegories and symbolism. That's what made older kid's movies and shows so good, they were written with typical writing techniques in mind, there's always meaning behind the words, the writers are always evoking an emotional reaction that all ages can relate to. Whereas modern kid's movies and shows are pretty much completely two dimensional, which is why movies like Toy Story will go down in history as 'literal magic in the form of a film reel'.[/QUOTE] Yeah, again, this is kind of what my videos are about. We could talk about consumerism and pushing merchandise (even though I think that's dead wrong), but that's not what I think John Lasseter's goal was. Even if it was, I explained pretty in depth what I felt Toy Story meant to me and to people like me. That's the whole point - sharing my appreciation of this film. I guess everyone has their standards for a 'reviewer' but I simply never claimed to be one. I make videos exactly for this reason: discussion. I agree that differing points and opinions will clearly occur, but if one is going to criticize the fact that I'm not pointing out certain things that I feel aren't even true or that I'm not criticizing the movie, then I feel they don't understand what I'm doing here. I want to talk about things on a more personal, emotion basis. This is of course not to object the "hyperbole" stuff, that I can agree with and take into consideration. However, I would have to say that a lot of today's cartoons are actually taking it back to the "good ol' days" (Adventure Time, Regular Show, Steven Universe, Clarence). A lot of them are my favorites now and actually have real substance, plot, and writing.

Oh god, when the shot from the stgggs "buried alive" video pops up in time with the word "grief".

[QUOTE=froztshock;48249162]Oh god, when the shot from the stgggs "buried alive" video pops up in time with the word "grief".[/QUOTE] YESS

"Do you suck dicks" got me real good.

The same thing I said before. I love your tone, but I think you should vary it throughout. It's awesome but it degrades quick if you're just constantly excited. It's the same reason why I don't watch PeanutButterGamer, even though I'm a fan of his writing. The tone just stays the same throughout and it gets really tiresome quick. When explaining plotline parts or things that don't need to be exasperated, you can come down a little bit more on the tone as it's not required to be super excited when you're talking about the more simple parts of the story. You should save the excitement for the parts that get you super excited, like the true meaning of the story, etc. and that way you'll pull the audience in more, as they'll be excited for these specific points that make you love the movie rather than for the entire thing. If there's no shift in tone, you're acting the same throughout. It's the same reason why we have pure bad and pure goods in the world, because if you don't have those things, then there's no sense of scale and nothing to grasp onto. It makes some audience members feel lost and when you're excited for everything, then you end up being excited for nothing, and that sucks cause I'd love to be taken on the same journey of incredible child-like wonder you're going through, you've just gotta help us get there and appeal to pathos.

Now I gotta watch all Toy Story movies again

I learned something from this video that probably wasn't intended. Joss Whedon worked on the Screenplay.

Fucking great video dude! I have watched toy story atleast 10 times but I still found myself watching the whole thing. Gotta say its great seeing a facepuncher releasing decent content instead of "hey guys check out my lets play" If you take requests for future videos Would ya do one on Hocus Pocus its my favorite kids movie of all time and I would to watch one of your style videos on it!

[QUOTE=TheFilmSlacker;48254737]Toy Story 3 is overrated as fuck.[/QUOTE] stop right there criminal scum [editline]20th July 2015[/editline] [QUOTE=matty928;48255115]Fucking great video dude! I have watched toy story atleast 10 times but I still found myself watching the whole thing. Gotta say its great seeing a facepuncher releasing decent content instead of "hey guys check out my lets play" If you take requests for future videos Would ya do one on Hocus Pocus its my favorite kids movie of all time and I would to watch one of your style videos on it![/QUOTE] oh shit dude HOCUS POCUS I FORGOT ABOUT THAT ONE. honestly dude, i might just look into that. that's not a bad idea at all. would be a nice halloween treat

And now I'm watching all the Toy Stories again. You did this to me.

[QUOTE=Rossy167;48244092]Gotta disagree with you there but Toy Story was all about that character development, meaning, allegories and symbolism. That's what made older kid's movies and shows so good, they were written with typical writing techniques in mind, there's always meaning behind the words, the writers are always evoking an emotional reaction that all ages can relate to. Whereas modern kid's movies and shows are pretty much completely two dimensional, which is why movies like Toy Story will go down in history as 'literal magic in the form of a film reel'.[/QUOTE] "Literal magic in the form of film reel" is a very unfortunate phrasing for an animated movie Additionally to that Toy Story one has a solid buddy adventure story to carry it but nothing more.

[QUOTE=Killuah;48262223]Additionally to that Toy Story one has a solid buddy adventure story to carry it but nothing more.[/QUOTE] Me and you did just watch the same video right?

I haven't seen toy story since I was little, I forgot how good it was. I genuinely teared up, I never realized how fucking deep the movie was. [editline]21st July 2015[/editline] Toy Story and its sequels are true 10/10 movies.

My mine comment is that I think you were mistaken about Woody trying to commit homicide. What he was trying to do was knock Buzz behind the desk, not out the window. That's why he looks so surprised himself when it happens.

[QUOTE=Rossy167;48264072]Me and you did just watch the same video right?[/QUOTE] Sure do. What do you disagree with? Is Toy Story not a buddy adventure story? The "new guy gotta get rid of him oh god I have to fix this" story has been told quite often. It's solid but not exceptional.

[QUOTE=Killuah;48266478]Sure do. What do you disagree with? Is Toy Story not a buddy adventure story? The "new guy gotta get rid of him oh god I have to fix this" story has been told quite often. It's solid but not exceptional.[/QUOTE] how oversimplified and applicable to literally every movie ever. while we're at it let's just strip it down even further to story types of 'man vs. man', 'man vs. self', etc. since we're gonna try to put this movie in its most plain form. especially since, you know, toy atory definitely doesn't add interesting to any of that to makes itself stand out (actually it does but i guess being incredibly cynical means no fun allowed). you could say the same thing about finding nemo, except that movie was also fucking incredible and brought something different to the table for what he story basically was at its core.

I think the man himself explains it pretty well without being cynical [url]http://www.rogerebert.com/reviews/toy-story-1995[/url] and tbh the only one with cynical and sarcastic tone here is you [editline]22nd July 2015[/editline] [quote] "Toy Story" is not as inventive in its plotting or as clever in its wit as "Rabbit" or such Disney animated films as "Beauty and the Beast"; it's pretty much a buddy movie transplanted to new terrain. Its best pleasures are for the eyes. But what pleasures they are![/quote] I don't know why you get so upset about this. It's true and there is no shame or being negative in seeing TS for what it is.

Yeah lol there's literally nothing wrong with calling toy story what it is. It's about two characters with different ideals who dislike each other, but have to set their differences aside to team up and save their friends, which fits the definition of a buddy adventure story down to a t. Calling ocean's eleven a heist movie doesn't make it bad, and neither does calling toy story a buddy adventure film.

I think it's a little disingenuous to call Toy Story JUST a buddy movie, or any movie, book, game or whatever JUST anything. Genres are great for distinguishing x from y. But while a movie like TS is a buddy movie at its core there is so much going on at the sides and in the background. Take the book Of Mice and Men for example, sure it's about two friends working on a ranch but at the same time it takes racial and gender issues, responsibility and loss, friendship and loneliness all in the backdrop of a crippling financial crisis. Don't tell me that shit is JUST a buddy book. TS might be less complex and nuanced than Of Mice and Men but it's still complex and nuanced.