MineCraft: Your Story - General

I will always prefer the first(?) minecraft song you made

No offense, but your taking it to far, We all know your not the best, and everyone can have their opinions, he thinks your bad, and thats not ignorance. "The fact that you can't accept that there is a good side to this, is scary." You said yourself it wasnt THAT great, now fuck off.

The instrumentals are good, but the vocals are just absolutely terrible. Try getting someone who can actually sing do the vocals. I don't mean to insult.

[QUOTE=billyman;25370092]he thinks your bad, and thats not ignorance.[/QUOTE] I never said that he was ignorant for saying I was bad, I said he was ignorant for stating "how could anyone listen to this, it is so horrible" when obviously people actually enjoy it. I don't mind that some people don't care for my vocals, that's their opinion, and they are entitled to it just as I am entitled to mine. It just irks me when someone says something like that, when it's not the question of "why can people listen to this", when they actually mean to say something like "I could never listen to this".

[QUOTE=xSlay3Rx;25368468]See this is where I start to fear for the human race. No offense, but it's ignorance like this that gets us nowhere. Ignorant in the sense that, yeah you may not like it, or understand why someone can, but somebody does. Someone out there listens to these. Just as there are millions of people who listen to hip hop or rap, and the other group who doesn't say the same thing you are saying now. The fact that you can't accept that there is a good side to this, is scary. It's like this. I extremely dislike country music. Having said that, it's not that I hate the people who make country music, I have respect for them as musicians, because I know what it is like to create music, perform music, etc. It just isn't something that I listen to, but I know that lots of people do, and I accept that. It's all about being a part of a society of different people, and if you can't accept that there are different people in the world, then I'm very sorry.[/QUOTE] lol, no. You're fearful for the human race because of a forum post that says your music is crap? Obviously a basement dweller haha. Seriously though you can't sing. I respect country music too for the skill. I'm a musician myself. I am telling you, on a musical basis, that you can't sing. Furthermore the music was uninteresting. I hate the fact people seem to want to praise you because you're the shiniest turd in the shitbowl (which I doubt you are anyway). [editline]13th October 2010[/editline] [QUOTE=xSlay3Rx;25373788]I don't mind that some people don't care for my vocals, that's their opinion, and they are entitled to it just as I am entitled to mine.[/QUOTE] Well you obviously do mind cause you got your panties in a twist when I said you can't sing for shit. [editline]13th October 2010[/editline] I just listened again to verify that you are, indeed, shit. Your voice sounds like a failing turbine you keep on moving up and down and you don't seem to be able to stick to holding a single note. Don't go telling me it's the style either because, in that case, change your style. Also it sounds like there's some autotune in there, if you used it then you suck, if you didn't then you suck for sounding like a broken vocoder.

Personally I think the vocals are excellent. [editline]13th October 2010[/editline] Is there autotune? I donät hear much autotune but I think I heard it on one note.

[QUOTE=xSlay3Rx;25330440]Hypocrisy at its' best. edit: Also, while I'm thinking about it I wanted to say something else. First of all, and this isn't about you I'm just saying, I'm never here on FacePunch to attack people, I'm always nice, I follow rules, I post stuff here because, what is the point of a forum if nobody contributes their own view? Having said that, I make a thread, and you post something like, "You're Stupid" and "Terrible at Singing" "Same boring shit, probably because you can't sing", and it's obviously a troll comment. Whether you are one or not, it's a 'troll' comment. You don't even provide any substance as to why you say these things, nor do you even provide suggestions, like Mr. Scorpio did. I don't mind that he said I need to work on my vocals, that is something I can work with, definitely. You saying I can't sing and I'm stupid, tells me nothing about myself because I'm not stupid, and I may not be the best singer in the world, but I can 'actually' sing. So all that I ask, is that you at least from here on out use better internet manners really, I think other people and not just myself would surely benefit from it. [editline]09:22AM[/editline] You're right, they aren't the greatest, I've never taken lessons, and I've only been singing for a few years.[/QUOTE] Whatever. You suck. My suggestion is for you to go and fuck yourself, because I don't care for giving you 'creative criticism'. I think you suck, simple as that. Also, cool holier-than-thou act. Get over yourself. I think anyone else with any sort of sense of what makes good music would agree with me, because really, your singing is just awful.

He he, you're a troll. this guy is a great singer and producer.

Awesome song.

[QUOTE=Eric95;25380372]He he, you're a troll. this guy is a great singer and producer.[/QUOTE] Presuming you're answering to me, you're too dumb to use quote, so I'm not sure. You need to stop throwing around 'troll'.

Make a song about facepunch... A facepunch anthem :allears:

[QUOTE=Calasmere;25380711]Presuming you're answering to me, you're too dumb to use quote, so I'm not sure. You need to stop throwing around 'troll'.[/QUOTE] Okay, this will be my last answer. The reason I didn't quote is because there was no post between your post and mine. "Troll" means that you aggravate people for your own amusement. I'm pretty sure that's what you're doing. Anyway, this song is great.

Well if there ever was a Facepunch anthem, it'd go something like... "Facepuuunnncchh... Is so awesommmmee... ... It's got coooll peopllleee... .... and then there are those like Calasmere and Lightbouuurrrnnnee..." edit: Also, setting all differences aside, I think it was a really cool thing to happen to me, that my minecraft song was used on national television. It really meant a lot to me that they wanted to use it, and no matter what anyone says about my music, all I ever did or am wanting to do with it are good things. edit #2: Also, I can understand Lightbourne, being a fellow musician and all (not really friendly, but whatever), if you feel kinda butt hurt because I'm actually trying to get my music out there and it's working. Maybe you should take some tips. Starting out with, how about making friends with other musicians, rather than telling them off? People in general really, not just musicians. You aren't going to get your music out there by being a selfish asshole. Why don't you collab or something, show em what teamwork is made of.

[QUOTE=Eric95;25382654]Okay, this will be my last answer. The reason I didn't quote is because there was no post between your post and mine. "Troll" means that you aggravate people for your own amusement. I'm pretty sure that's what you're doing. Anyway, this song is great.[/QUOTE] This just in: 15 year old boy on the internet dictates the definition of slang. I'm not aggravating for amusement. I'm saying it's shit because it's shit.

[QUOTE=Calasmere;25404051]This just in: 15 year old boy on the internet dictates the definition of slang. I'm not aggravating for amusement. I'm saying it's shit because it's shit.[/QUOTE] Just because you think it's shit, doesn't mean it IS shit. The world doesn't revolve around you. If you said a red car was a yellow car, it doesn't make the car yellow. There is a difference between opinion, and what actually IS. Also... [U][media][/U][URL]http://youtube.com/watch?v=dNNPdWjQQoQ[/URL][/media] [editline]14th October 2010[/editline] [QUOTE=Calasmere;25380286]Whatever. You suck. My suggestion is for you to go and fuck yourself, because I don't care for giving you 'creative criticism'. I think you suck, simple as that. Also, cool holier-than-thou act. Get over yourself.[/QUOTE] Oh I'm sorry, I just have this really nice way of getting along with people, it's easy really and it's not an act or for show whatsoever. It's called 'being nice to people'. Try it sometime, maybe you'll get more friends or less dumb ratings. I could have easily have said 'gtfo' or 'go fuck yourself' several posts ago, but that is such an easy cop-out of an argument. Obviously since you have used one of these, you must be starting to become aggravated at the fact that you are starting to realize that your opinion doesn't affect me, and isn't going to make me cry or something, so really honestly I'm very sorry that I haven't gotten upset. Maybe one day you will find someone who will become mad at you so you can feel complete again.

You sound a bit like the lead singer from stereophonics

You're not the best singer in the world, I suggest taking lessons.

[QUOTE=xSlay3Rx;25405163]Just because you think it's shit, doesn't mean it IS shit. The world doesn't revolve around you. If you said a red car was a yellow car, it doesn't make the car yellow. There is a difference between opinion, and what actually IS. Also... [U][media][/U][URL]http://youtube.com/watch?v=dNNPdWjQQoQ[/URL][/media] [editline]14th October 2010[/editline] Oh I'm sorry, I just have this really nice way of getting along with people, it's easy really and it's not an act or for show whatsoever. It's called 'being nice to people'. Try it sometime, maybe you'll get more friends or less dumb ratings. I could have easily have said 'gtfo' or 'go fuck yourself' several posts ago, but that is such an easy cop-out of an argument. Obviously since you have used one of these, you must be starting to become aggravated at the fact that you are starting to realize that your opinion doesn't affect me, and isn't going to make me cry or something, so really honestly I'm very sorry that I haven't gotten upset. Maybe one day you will find someone who will become mad at you so you can feel complete again.[/QUOTE] Being nice to people? You're being condescending. I understand my opinion is not fact, need you tell me? No. Your singing is shit. Do I need to add 'in my opinion'? NOPE. It's my opinion. Deal with it.

[QUOTE=Calasmere;25419348]Being nice to people? You're being condescending. I understand my opinion is not fact, need you tell me? No. Your singing is shit. Do I need to add 'in my opinion'? NOPE. It's my opinion. Deal with it.[/QUOTE] I really don't think that showing respect to others is being condescending at all :/

[QUOTE=DeandreT;25285224]You need to stop. I can't stop listening to this music because of you.[/QUOTE] So much, this.

[QUOTE=XCIV;25285248]Interesting song but dude, you're killing me. RHYME IN YOUR SONGS. Every sentence, rhyme them alright man?[/QUOTE] thats called rap you idiot.

Amazing, Just pure Gold.

[QUOTE=xSlay3Rx;25383970]edit #2: Also, I can understand Lightbourne, being a fellow musician and all (not really friendly, but whatever), if you feel kinda butt hurt because I'm actually trying to get my music out there and it's working. Maybe you should take some tips. Starting out with, how about making friends with other musicians, rather than telling them off? People in general really, not just musicians. You aren't going to get your music out there by being a selfish asshole. Why don't you collab or something, show em what teamwork is made of.[/QUOTE] Yes I'm feeling butt hurt because you're trying to get your music out there and it's most definitely "working". I should definitely take tips from you about making friends with people that post on forums. I should definitely collab with you, even though you can't sing, because that'd be the nice thing to do and it'd show "em". Oh also I definitely don't have anything better to do. The fact that you're getting your knickers in a twist over these forum posts just shows how highly you rate this thread which leads me to doubt and success you seem to think you're having. Normally I'd end by wishing people luck but, to be honest, you're so jaded I doubt luck would do you any good at this point.

[QUOTE=Lightbourne;25479095]Yes I'm feeling butt hurt because you're trying to get your music out there and it's most definitely "working". I should definitely take tips from you about making friends with people that post on forums. I should definitely collab with you, even though you can't sing, because that'd be the nice thing to do and it'd show "em". Oh also I definitely don't have anything better to do. The fact that you're getting your knickers in a twist over these forum posts just shows how highly you rate this thread which leads me to doubt and success you seem to think you're having. Normally I'd end by wishing people luck but, to be honest, you're so jaded I doubt luck would do you any good at this point.[/QUOTE] Thanks for bumping my thread, I really appreciate it. Now more people can listen to my song, and read a bunch of nonsense posts!

[QUOTE=xSlay3Rx;25479198]Thanks for bumping my thread, I really appreciate it. Now more people can listen to my song, and read a bunch of nonsense posts![/QUOTE] I swear if you didn't post pictures of yourself in your videos I'd think you're a kid. You did post this video for a discussion on it, right? If so start acting like an adult and reply, if not then stop posting these videos.

[QUOTE=Lightbourne;25479282]I swear if you didn't post pictures of yourself in your videos I'd think you're a kid. You did post this video for a discussion on it, right? If so start acting like an adult and reply, if not then stop posting these videos.[/QUOTE] I have been replying actually, and most actively. I really don't feel I have been acting childish at all, compared to all the people who are like "You're shit" "go fuck yourself" "*sarcasm* *sarcasm* you are jaded", when I've done nothing to provoke that kind of behavior. I merely was posting my music for people to listen to, and other people got out of control with their comments. I've done nothing to anybody that has sincerely provoked someone. Also, (and not to be childish or anything), but it's really hard to reply or have a discussion when someone's post is "You can't sing" or "You're shit" fyi. Having a discussion would be, "I didn't really enjoy it, how long have you sung for?" or "I think your voice sounds bad, maybe it wouldn't hurt for you to have lessons". I don't know, something to discuss about.

Aw, when I heard you say "Minecraft" the way you did at 4 minutes, I thought for sure you were going to bring back the "Minecraft, talkin' 'bout minecraft" chorus from your other song.