https://files.facepunch.com/forum/upload/189/52cfbc48-af4f-483e-af89-a5d347af9b59/agree.png
Agree's random breaks in outline do look a bit jarring.
I love these icons tbh.
I feel like informative is kind of an eye sore because of how squished down it looks. Also artistic isnt obvious, as it just looks like a bucket. It was arguably better when it was a brush.
I feel like the new icons in the ratings look rather bad on computers when they're that small, as the broken lines just look naff at the low resolution. I wonder if it might be worthwhile to make new versions for the ratings that have somewhat thicker outlines.
They're neat, but i'm not personally a big fan.
I think it might be because they look strange, probably has to do with them being shrunk down. The small ratings shouldn't be as detailed I feel because those small details don't look good on the small icon.
Really liking the new icons, though I still think dumb box should be the old classic flat empty dumb box instead of the current closed one.
Loving the frequency in updates especially with the update drought the last month or so.
these are interesting icons, still not used to them but i kinda like the cartoony style
Love the new icons! Previous ones were difficult for me to differentiate at a glance, i have very poor vision. These are much better!
yeah, sometimes I'm just used to the old ones and looking for H&S forum
give it few days to settle in
Yeah the ratings really need to be as simple as possible with a focus on readability over detail. You can't even make out the small faces in cute, good idea and asshole ratings, others like big woop, informative and winner are also cluttered with fine detail that doesn't display well.
Yeah I loved the new forum icons, but I don't like the rating icons. They really look too detailed to be used on such a small scale.
Icon Debate Punch, closing this thread.
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.