[QUOTE=Rocky Rickaby;13248119]Since when did you know aboot comics?[/QUOTE]
Always would be my guess. I'd sell my left kidney for a madmanmad comic.
[b]Edit:[/b]
Holy fuck you guys, what the hell happened?
Could we stop the fighting, guys? I know it's tough to just restrain from replying, but seriously, could we stop the unnecessary flaming?
[QUOTE=usaokay;13254966]
Off-topic: Ignore Rubs Glue, this is just another silly event just like Rambo_6 and those Timeroller comics. Just ignore it and all of this will be in the past.[/QUOTE]
Someone insulted my internet friend :(
[QUOTE=archie200034;13254174]A personal attack indicates that you're out of arguments.[/quote]
"Get the fuck out" isn't really a personal attack, but okay. If you say he's out of arguments you must not have read [I]his[/I] post.
[quote=archie200034]I have never claimed that this guy doesn't know what he's doing.[/QUOTE]
"Movie critics know what they're talking about, his point is that this guy doesn't."
You worded it as if you agreed with GoldenBullet.
[QUOTE=usaokay;13255420]wut now[/QUOTE]
What? Sorry, that should have been put in quotes. That was a rewrite of your original post.
[QUOTE=usaokay;13254966]Off-topic: Ignore Rubs Glue, this is just another silly event just like Rambo_6 and those Timeroller comics. Just ignore it and all of this will be in the past.[/QUOTE]
They gave criticism and got shit for it?
If it offends the Creator it is not constrictive as the Creator will never listen to it.
The general rules of criticism is that you don't stand around. If the person you are criticizing responds negatively toward you comments hop on your high horse and ride off. Staying around just makes both of you dicks.
[QUOTE=Wearwolf;13255625]
The general rules of criticism is that you don't stand around. If the person you are criticizing responds negatively toward you comments hop on your high horse and ride off. Staying around just makes both of you dicks.[/QUOTE]
General rules, what are those? Where are they located, because last time I checked; criticism [I]doesn't[/I] have rules. Criticism is pointing out the flaws in something, which is exactly what I did.
[QUOTE=Rubs Glue;13255217]"Get the fuck out" isn't really a personal attack, but okay. If you say he's out of arguments you must not have read [I]his[/I] post.
[/QUOTE]
It depends on if I take it as a personal attack, and if he needs to tell people to "get the fuck out" then I'd say he's pretty low on arguments.. And yes I agree with GoldenBullet to some point, but this is all getting very silly. Lets stop this now.
[QUOTE=archie200034;13256065]If he needs to tell people to "get the fuck out" then I'd say he's pretty low on arguments..[/quote]
What are you talking about, "get the fuck out" was the preface to his actual comment. Have you even read [I]anything[/I] that's been posted in this thread?
[quote=archie200000000000034]And yes I agree with GoldenBullet to some point[/QUOTE]
If he was correct, why are you complaining?
Sound effect text needs more scene approprate color/text style. Yellow, and light blue doesn't really go too good with murder
[QUOTE=Rubs Glue;13255918]General rules, what are those? Where are they located, because last time I checked; criticism [I]doesn't[/I] have rules. Criticism is pointing out the flaws in something, which is exactly what I did.[/QUOTE]
The generally accepted rules among society. Everyone should know them already.
Basically common sense.
That is unless you are trying to be a dick, in which case keep going.
[QUOTE=archie200034;13256065]It depends on if I take it as a personal attack, and if he needs to tell people to "get the fuck out" then I'd say he's pretty low on arguments.. And yes I agree with GoldenBullet to some point, but this is all getting very silly. Lets stop this now.[/QUOTE]
So, I tell you to get the fuck out (why are you still here? [B]GET OUT[/B]) and it instantly makes me out of arguments? [I]Even though I had more to say immediately after the comment, which was clearly posted?[/I] For some reason, I don't think you read any of my post at all, and only saw some offensive comment torwards yourself, in which case you had to defend your reputation (or lack of) by posting even more [B]inconsistent BULLSHIT[/B] than what's already coming out of your drivel-spouting brain just to make it appear as if you are winning some benign argument, just because the OP can't take criticism and you and he [B]decide to defend him just by keeping up this argument in the first place.[/B]
[QUOTE=Wearwolf;13256319]The generally accepted rules among society. Everyone should know them already.
Basically common sense.[/quote]
Wait, so now the [I]"generally accepted rules among society"[/I] are now the [I]"general rules of criticism[/I] ? Holy shit, what rock of I been living under? Man, I must lack [B]all the common sense in the world[/B] !
[quote=Wearwolf]That is unless you are trying to be a dick, in which case keep going.[/QUOTE]
I'm the only one "trying to be a dick" in this thread, and I am [I][B]definitely [/B][/I]one for defending myself. Get out.
[QUOTE=someone;13256359]So, I tell you to get the fuck out (why are you still here? [B]GET OUT[/B]) and it instantly makes me out of arguments? [I]Even though I had more to say immediately after the comment, which was clearly posted?[/I] For some reason, I don't think you read any of my post at all, and only saw some offensive comment torwards yourself, in which case you had to defend your reputation (or lack of) by posting even more [B]inconsistent BULLSHIT[/B] than what's already coming out of your drivel-spouting brain just to make it appear as if you are winning some benign argument, just because the OP can't take criticism and you and he [B]decide to defend him just by keeping up this argument in the first place.[/B][/QUOTE]
Just a question, but why tell someone to get out and then argue with them?
[QUOTE=Wearwolf;13256390]Just a question, but why tell someone to get out and then argue with them?[/QUOTE]
[B]Because they aren't getting out[/B]
[QUOTE=Wearwolf;13256319]That is unless you are trying to be a dick, in which case keep going.[/QUOTE]
He posts criticism and everyone else gets butthurt about it. I'm pretty sure it's [I]everyone else[/I] who's being the assholes. Why? It's not even [I]their comic.[/I] "Oh, boo-hoo, my friend's lack of talent and shoddy work got attacked! I better go [B]make an idiot of myself.[/B]"
[QUOTE=5omeone;13256419]He posts criticism and everyone else gets butthurt about it. I'm pretty sure it's [I]everyone else[/I] who's being the assholes.[/QUOTE]
Well of course. Then everyone else got butthurt over those folks being butthurt, which made the first folks even more butthurt...
[QUOTE=Wearwolf;13256442]Well of course. Then everyone else got butthurt over those folks being butthurt, which made the first folks even more butthurt...[/QUOTE]
"I lost focus because I didn't read the thread and posted idiotic remarks, in which case were trump-carded easily, so I will post some semi-philosophical remark that makes me look even twice as dumb as I looked before."
[highlight](User was banned for this post ("Flaming" - Uberslug))[/highlight]
As long as we understand each other.
[QUOTE=5omeone;13256359]So, I tell you to get the fuck out (why are you still here? [B]GET OUT[/B])[/QUOTE]
Make me.
[QUOTE=5omeone;13256359] and it instantly makes me out of arguments? [I]Even though I had more to say immediately after the comment, which was clearly posted?[/I][/QUOTE]
Not really, But you must be running out of arguments if you need to tell people to "get the fuck out" to win an argumentation.
[QUOTE=5omeone;13256359] For some reason, I don't think you read any of my post at all, and only saw some offensive comment torwards yourself, in which case you had to defend your reputation (or lack of) by posting even more [B]inconsistent BULLSHIT[/B][/QUOTE]
I don't really care what you think
[QUOTE=5omeone;13256359]than what's already coming out of your drivel-spouting brain[/Quote]
Flaming
[QUOTE=5omeone;13256359]just to make it appear as if you are winning some benign argument, just because the OP can't take criticism and you and he [B]decide to defend him just by keeping up this argument in the first place.[/B][/QUOTE]
[b]LEAVE GB ALONE, LEAVE HIM ALONE![/b] ;-;
Summed up:
[QUOTE=5omeone;13256359] GTFO, I think this, I think that, You suck, Stop defending OP[/Quote]
Lol no
This thread makes happy monkey cry.
[QUOTE=archie200034;13260148]Make me.
Not really, But you must be running out of arguments if you need to tell people to "get the fuck out" to win an argumentation.
I don't really care what you think
Flaming
[b]LEAVE GB ALONE, LEAVE HIM ALONE![/b] ;-;
Summed up:
Lol no[/QUOTE]
[B]Looks like [I]you're[/I] the one that's run out of arguments[/B]
[img]http://xs135.xs.to/xs135/09036/1230782334264470.jpg[/img]
[QUOTE=Rubs Glue;13263998][B]Looks like [I]you're[/I] the one that's run out of arguments[/B]
[img]http://xs135.xs.to/xs135/09036/1230782334264470.jpg[/img][/QUOTE]
To be honest, i like you. Nice to have some variation in the fp community.
On-topic, i agree that i should use a diferent font and colours for the text effects :)
Alrighty, here we go:
[b]Posing:[/b]
Overall: pretty good, some flaws here and there (a guy who has been shot didn't carry a weapon for some reason), and a wee bit of clipping here and there
[b]Story:[/b]
Low score on this one, although I know it was d-day (and omaha beach) it didn't have much of a story...
Although this is acceptable because its editing practice
[b]Editing:[/b]
This is the part where it gets ugly, I'll give you a list of things to look after and improve:
-Text is really bad, the colors distract from the comic and aren't fitting at all
-Practice alot with the burn and dodge tool, "but I'm lazy" is not an exuse for not isolating the area you want to edit first (especially in a comic which you created for editing practice)
-The explosions in the water are waaaay too blue, it looks really out of place and ugly
-The smoke is way too white and thick, fix it
-The anime face was really unnessecary and makes me wonder if this was supposed to be serious or funny
[b]Overall:[/b]
Posing: 9.0
Story: 5.0
Editing: 5.0
Overall: 6.3
My recommendation: try to think about the things I and other people in this thread told you next time
[QUOTE=turtlehead;13265421]Alrighty, here we go:
[b]Posing:[/b]
Overall: pretty good, some flaws here and there (a guy who has been shot didn't carry a weapon for some reason), and a wee bit of clipping here and there
[b]Story:[/b]
Low score on this one, although I know it was d-day (and omaha beach) it didn't have much of a story...
Although this is acceptable because its editing practice
[b]Editing:[/b]
This is the part where it gets ugly, I'll give you a list of things to look after and improve:
-Text is really bad, the colors distract from the comic and aren't fitting at all
-Practice alot with the burn and dodge tool, "but I'm lazy" is not an exuse for not isolating the area you want to edit first (especially in a comic which you created for editing practice)
-The explosions in the water are waaaay too blue, it looks really out of place and ugly
-The smoke is way too white and thick, fix it
-The anime face was really unnessecary and makes me wonder if this was supposed to be serious or funny
[b]Overall:[/b]
Posing: 9.0
Story: 5.0
Editing: 5.0
Overall: 6.3
My recommendation: try to think about the things I and other people in this thread told you next time[/QUOTE]
Thanks, i will try and spend more time on editing next time and make sure i get a second opinion on the final work and apply necessary changes before posting.
That was.....................Short.
[QUOTE=GoldenBullet;13248353]Usually i would appreciate critisism, but to be honest you haven't posted a single comic and you didn't tell me how to improve what i was doing, basically you just ranted about it even though i'm 100% positive you can't do any better.
Oh, and since when is saying somethings 'shitty' an effective way of describing something? It just makes you sound like a hooligan with a pathetic vocabulary.[/QUOTE]
He pointed out your flaws and told you what to improove one, and gave you strong Critisism. And it does not matter if he has done a comic (or if he hasn't done a comic), he still gave you critisism. Stop acting whining, take it like a man, read your critisism wich you appiciate so much (well that is what you tell us) and improove!
[QUOTE=Jim_Riley;13236470]And the way I see it is that the only reason why it probably took the Brits "2 hours" to clear their beach was because they didn't have nearly as much a concentration of defence as Omaha not to mention they didn't fight the most experienced German defenders either, the 352nd ID. Sorry.[/QUOTE]
Are you saying that the yanks on our beaches didn't have it tough!!! Thounsands of good old blightey (Britian) solidiers died taking those beeches! We were one the most affected by WW2. I'm not saying no one else was affected cuase people did have it worse of then us but we were the ones who were being bombed every bloody night!
I raise my orange juice to you my good British friend.
British FTW.
[QUOTE=lechimp89;13522559]Are you saying that the yanks on our beaches didn't have it tough!!! Thounsands of good old blightey (Britian) solidiers died taking those beeches! We were one the most affected by WW2. I'm not saying no one else was affected cuase people did have it worse of then us but we were the ones who were being bombed every bloody night![/QUOTE]
Yeah, I'm not saying Omaha did ALL the work and I'm just merely stating the facts when, realistically, they were all tough objectives but if you were to have a statistical comparison of the two I still stand by what I said previously. The whole point of the Normandy Campaign was a joint operation for the Allies and all that. Team work, we're in this together and all that crap. I know Britain got to taste the experimental V1/V2 rockets firsthand though.
Of course, the Germans should know anything if not [i]everything[/i] about being "bombed every bloody night". Pounded by two fronts coming together is not cool.
Russia, by the way, was probably most affected by WWII though. No denying it. World relations with one another (Specifically US/Russia relations) today can almost be directly related to the outcome of both World Wars.
But I'm just saying...
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.
