• German Transgendered girl Alex, has been institutionalized.
    301 replies, posted
This is disgusting (German Government's decision, not her obviously), Gender Dysphoria is [b]NOT[/b] caused by "spending too much time with your mother"! What the fuck are you doing Germany? Where's the progressiveness that made it so Women were completely equal in your armed forces. [editline]24th March 2012[/editline] [QUOTE=Splendor;35274107]He is a wee bit too young to be making decisions like that. Kids make dumb decisions.[/QUOTE] Why is there [b]ALWAYS[/b] like 90 replies in these threads that say the same exact thing. The Mother supporter her choice and believed it was rational. The Father was an ignorant jerk and didn't.
[QUOTE=QueenSasha24;35274451]This is disgusting (German Government's decision, not her obviously), Gender Dysphoria is [b]NOT[/b] caused by "spending too much time with your mother"! [/QUOTE] If the google translation really said it like that, then that is a mistranslation. It was assumed that the mother "talked the TS into the child". Not much better really, but not QUITE as stupid...
Nothing like a trans story to draw out the transphobic people. People that use the wrong pronouns on purpose are just asking to start some shit.
[QUOTE=Atlessa;35274528]If the google translation really said it like that, then that is a mistranslation. It was assumed that the mother "talked the TS into the child". Not much better really, but not QUITE as stupid...[/QUOTE] I guess not quite as stupid but still an extremely ridiculous accusation. Why would a Mother talk her child into becoming one of the most difficult to be Groups of people in the world?
From a friends better translation, it seems that although it has not been done yet, it has been ruled that it will be allowed to happen, unless the mother's appeal to the decision can stop it. [editline]24th March 2012[/editline] Updated main post with better translation.
I have translated the news report as best as I could. Furthermore, this is not done by Nazis. Sadly, this is done by ignorant people. People you can find anywhere on this world. And the nurse is claiming the mother has induced the transsexuality. Not that it has been caused by spending too much time with the mother alone.
[QUOTE=Darkon Ta Dra;35274682]I have translated the news report as best as I could. Furthermore, this is not done by Nazis. Sadly, this is done by ignorant people. People you can find anywhere on this world. And the nurse is claiming the mother has induced the transsexuality. Not that it has been caused by spending too much time with the mother alone.[/QUOTE] Thankyou very much for the translation.
You are welcome my dear. I'm glad I can contribute.
[QUOTE=Darkon Ta Dra;35274682]I have translated the news report as best as I could. Furthermore, this is not done by Nazis. Sadly, this is done by ignorant people. People you can find anywhere on this world. And the nurse is claiming the mother has induced the transsexuality. Not that it has been caused by spending too much time with the mother alone.[/QUOTE] Yes, thank you very much for the translation.
[QUOTE=Darkon Ta Dra;35274722]You are welcome my dear. I'm glad I can contribute.[/QUOTE] Though I don't know how you got my name wrong, you spelt it Kartina?
Oops, sorry Nekosune. Must have been a typo. @The Golden: As a german myself, I can say it is these backwards bureaucrats who give us a bad name. Of course there are stupid and ignorant people here. Like anywhere else. But I have also met many tolerant and accepting people. Including myself I hope. On the other hand, there are similar issues in many other countries, including USA and UK. That of course doesn't make Germany any better. But not worse either. I think stupid/ignorant/backwards people are a global problem.
I'm so proud of being german right now. Finally this bullshit's being handled the right way. [highlight](User was banned for this post ("General homophobia - can't tell if troll or just a dick" - Lithifold))[/highlight]
[QUOTE=shadow_006;35275755]I'm so proud of being german right now. Finally this bullshit's being handled the right way.[/QUOTE] I really hope you're being sarcastic.
[QUOTE=shadow_006;35275755]I'm so proud of being german right now. Finally this bullshit's being handled the right way.[/QUOTE] Are you kidding me?
[QUOTE=shadow_006;35275755]I'm so proud of being german right now. Finally this bullshit's being handled the right way.[/QUOTE] Go die.
The thing is, WE are trying to handle it properly. Unfortunately, the Berlin bureaucracy does not. And to think Berlins mayor Klaus Wowereit is gay. One would wonder that he would have more understanding for LGBT rights. Still, I am proud to be german also. Despite what germans have done in the past and the present.
[QUOTE=Darkon Ta Dra;35276046]The thing is, WE are trying to handle it properly. Unfortunately, the Berlin bureaucracy does not. And to think Berlins mayor Klaus Wowereit is gay. One would wonder that he would have more understanding for LGBT rights. Still, I am proud to be german also. Despite what germans have done in the past and the present.[/QUOTE] Many LGBT people forget the "T" in LGBT when it really comes down to the wire it seems.
[QUOTE=Darkon Ta Dra;35276046]The thing is, WE are trying to handle it properly. Unfortunately, the Berlin bureaucracy does not. And to think Berlins mayor Klaus Wowereit is gay. One would wonder that he would have more understanding for LGBT rights. Still, I am proud to be german also. Despite what germans have done in the past and the present.[/QUOTE] Once gays started getting treated better by society at large their movement largely left trans* people in the dust, unfortunately
[QUOTE=Griffster26;35273065]Get out[/QUOTE] it's funny because the nazi's wanted to get rid of gay people too [editline]24th March 2012[/editline] [QUOTE=agentgamma;35276037]Go die.[/QUOTE] SOMEONE DOESNT AGREE WITH ME I HOPE THEY DIE
[QUOTE=shadow_006;35275755]I'm so proud of being german right now. Finally this bullshit's being handled the right way.[/QUOTE] Youre a sick fucker.
[QUOTE=Lazor;35276100]Once gays started getting treated better by society at large their movement largely left trans* people in the dust, unfortunately[/QUOTE] Sad but true.
[img]http://www.leftycartoons.com/wp-content/uploads/LGB-and-also-T-5751.png[/img]
[QUOTE=shadow_006;35275755]I'm so proud of being german right now. Finally this bullshit's being handled the right way.[/QUOTE] C'mon, mister shadow aught-aught-six, you've been here longer than [I]I[/I] have. Surely you've got to have some kind of human decency and/or empathy.
I don't even have any response to their decision. I can't understand why they would do this.
Jane Fae's blog, and this whole situation really, reminded me of this movie my class watched in Psychology about either Reimer or Murphy. Basically, because of an accident during circumcision, their penis was destroyed, and they decided to bring him up as a girl. If that case alone doesn't convince someone that you can't just "treat" someone into being a different gender, I don't know what could.
There used to be a much better cartoon based on a similar subject, but unfortunatly the tumblr has been shut down that had it on.
[QUOTE=shadow_006;35275755]I'm so proud of being german right now. Finally this bullshit's being handled the right way. [highlight](User was banned for this post ("General homophobia - can't tell if troll or just a dick" - Lithifold))[/highlight][/QUOTE] Using homophobia in relation to his other bans, btw, I know the term is transphobia. It's sad what has happened here, I remember the thread where they were considering doing this. I hope the UK doesn't follow suit and goes through with the talks of legalising gay marriage here (and by marriage, I mean a marriage that's CALLED a marriage, not a civil partnership). I know this isn't a gay marriage issue, but more to the point that if a person transitions who is married in this country, their marriage is voided.
[QUOTE=Ray-The-Sun;35276298]C'mon, mister shadow aught-aught-six, you've been here longer than [I]I[/I] have. Surely you've got to have some kind of human decency and/or empathy.[/QUOTE] You'd be surprised.
If he was institutionalized without proper reason doesn't that mean he'll get "released" rather fast ?
[QUOTE=Ganerumo;35276444]If he was institutionalized without proper reason doesn't that mean he'll get "released" rather fast ?[/QUOTE] She, and unfortunatly not, Like the ex gay therapy camps in USA, there are places in Germany that believe, gay and Trans is something you get rid of with therapy/
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.