• German Transgendered girl Alex, has been institutionalized.
    301 replies, posted
[QUOTE=acds;35277802]Don't see how that makes it such a unassailable fact that thinking otherwise makes it trolling and a bannable offence. Refer to above, I'm not talking about it being right or wrong, I'm saying that having a different opinion on the matter is not trolling. As above, not talking about it being right or wrong, just that this isn't an indisputable fact, not talking about GID, I'm saying that her being institutionalized being wrong is not a fact, so when he says he thinks it's right, it's his opinion on the matter, [B]opinion[/B], and stating your opinion on something that is up for debate (yeah sorry, just because most of FP thinks one way it doesn't make it undisputable fact) and that isn't trolling. For the record, I don't agree with him (I think they should have let an expert decide), but I don't want everyone who doesn't think like me banned.[/QUOTE] terrible backwards opinions are bannable, as they should be. get over it dude [editline]1[/editline] if you want the freedom to post retarded shit, go on youtube or something
[QUOTE=proch;35277828]And because some fucking idiots (like there are many in every country) did stupid shit, there now are people calling the whole country "nazi". I fucking hate when people generalize like this. Seriously, don't advocate such behavior.[/QUOTE] Seriously, Germany is a very progressive Nation now, just because a few assholes decide to be well, assholes, doesn't mean the entire country is a bunch of Nazis, World War 2 was over 60 years ago and didn't involve nearly anyone in modern day Germany, get over it already people. And in relation to this story, I hold true to my statement that the Father who is forcing her to this Institution, the Nurse who made her stupid bullshit theory, and the German council members that approved this, are all either so misguided they couldn't find up, or they're so bigoted and stupid that they can't see that this will KILL this girl.
[QUOTE=Drsalvador;35277211] What [I]"issue"[/I]? [B]WHO GIVES A FUCK HOW OTHER PEOPLE WANT TO LIVE THEIR LIVES?[/B][/QUOTE] As you can see: at least one court in germany does. And that is one court too many.
[QUOTE=acds;35277802]Don't see how that makes it such a unassailable fact that thinking otherwise makes it trolling and a bannable offence.[/QUOTE] [QUOTE=Lithifold;35276405]in relation to his other bans[/QUOTE] Congratulations on having a shitposting fit over your inability to read. Care to say anything meaningful now that that's been cleared up? [QUOTE=acds;35277802]I'm saying that her being institutionalized being wrong is not a fact[/QUOTE] If you hear that someone is hospitalized for heart problems, namely, an accumulation of cardiovascular weasels, the statement that they've been wrongly diagnosed is indeed a fact. You're just trying to make an argument because, as has been established, you're something of a prick on this subject.
I hope he gets good treatment from this.
Goddammit Germany!!!
[QUOTE=HighdefGE;35278553]I hope he gets good treatment from this.[/QUOTE]Uhh, why? First of all, its "She" and second of all, there is nothing wrong or broken about her.
Are you fucking kidding me?
[QUOTE=Sanius;35277837]terrible backwards opinions are bannable, as they should be. get over it dude [editline]1[/editline] if you want the freedom to post retarded shit, go on youtube or something[/QUOTE] or reddit lmao
[QUOTE=acds;35277802] Refer to above, I'm not talking about it being right or wrong, I'm saying that having a different opinion on the matter is not trolling. [/QUOTE] Some opinions are so awful that they will get you banned. Making posts stating your opinion on why <insert race here> is bad will get you banned. I don't see why saying transgenders are bullshit should be any different.
So if I get this right, she's getting locked up in a nut house without proper care, and people are going to attempt at "fixing" something that they believe is a mental issue while a part of the "syndromes" of gender identity disorders are actually more of a physical matter, without neither the consent of the kid nor of her mother ? Did we just jump back to the late fifties or something ?
[QUOTE=Ganerumo;35279736] Did we just jump back to the late fifties or something ?[/QUOTE] [img]http://application.denofgeek.com/pics/film/marty.doc02.jpg[/img] [b]"Doc we've gone back in time!" "No Marty it's just a German mental health facility."[/b]
Lets institutionalize the nurse so she can help Alex through this rough time.
[quote] The nurse found, that the mother had 'induced' the childs transsexuality, and therefore Alex had to be removed from her sphere of influence.[/quote] really? am i really reading this?
[QUOTE=thisispain;35282305]really? am i really reading this?[/QUOTE] it's bollocks i know, but she's a 'trained professional' and you must understand that she is an expert
[QUOTE=Megafan;35282561]it's bollocks i know, but she's a 'trained professional' and you must understand that she is an expert[/QUOTE] i don't have to understand anything, that's the beauty of news.
[QUOTE=thisispain;35282619]i don't have to understand anything, that's the beauty of news.[/QUOTE] it's infotainment! *now with 0% concentrated info
[QUOTE=Megafan;35282694] *now with 0% concentrated info[/QUOTE] Too much information, tone it down a little. Thinking is hard man, where's your compassion?
[QUOTE=Jetblack357;35277740]No, not at all. Read up on biology sometime, its pretty interesting.[/QUOTE] I don't think he's not in understanding on the subject. He's just making a joke don't be so serious.
[QUOTE=Boxbot219;35279661]Some opinions are so awful that they will get you banned. Making posts stating your opinion on why <insert race here> is bad will get you banned. I don't see why saying transgenders are bullshit should be any different.[/QUOTE] There's a far fucking gap between racism and transgenders don't even try comparing the two. [editline]24th March 2012[/editline] [QUOTE=Elecbullet;35282790]I don't think he's not in understanding on the subject. He's just making a joke don't be so serious.[/QUOTE] [media]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ussCHoQttyQ[/media]
[QUOTE=Jetblack357;35283018]There's a far fucking gap between racism and transgenders don't even try comparing the two.[/QUOTE] Are you even aware of the sheer amount of hate crimes committed against trans people? It's similar enough that you can compare the two, they're two groups of people who are hated for [b]extremely stupid reasons[/b].
[QUOTE=Jetblack357;35283018]There's a far fucking gap between racism and transgenders don't even try comparing the two.[/QUOTE] Blatant homophobia and transphobia will get you banned about as much as racism will. You should know from experience.
the fact that ppl can even be institutionalized at all is such a terrible prospect
[QUOTE=Kung Fu Jew;35283292]the fact that ppl can even be institutionalized at all is such a terrible prospect[/QUOTE] It is needed sometimes, for people who's mental health makes them a danger to other people.
[QUOTE=Megafan;35283109]Blatant homophobia and transphobia will get you banned about as much as racism will. You should know from experience.[/QUOTE] Really, like last time I posted a comment that was in no way offensive and you banned me for it? Yeah I remember. Though the first two I did have coming.
[QUOTE=Jetblack357;35283018]There's a far fucking gap between racism and transgenders don't even try comparing the two.[/QUOTE] What? They are perfectly comparable. There are people who hate other races purely out of ignorance and there are people who hate transgender people out of ignorance. There have been hate crimes committed against people based on race and there have been hate crimes committed against people based on them being transgender. I fail to see this "far gap" that makes the two incomparable. And in this case there are people who treat transgender people like they are diseased and in need of a cure.
This article title is very misleading She's not institutionalized, she's only been declared that she "legally could be institutionalized" Wither or not she actually becomes institutionalized is another issue, but that doesn't mean she doesn't have time to gain support and appeal the decision. Or run out of the country or something.
[QUOTE=KorJax;35283448]This article title is very misleading She's not institutionalized, she's only been declared that she "legally could be institutionalized" Wither or not she actually becomes institutionalized is another issue, but that doesn't mean she doesn't have time to gain support and appeal the decision. Or run out of the country or something.[/QUOTE] When I made the thread, I only had google translate, and what a friend had told me, when a different friend translated, I saw it was only could be, still, it is a LOT more likely to happen now then it was before, and the emphasis is no longer on the father fighting for it, but the mother fighting against it, which is harder to stop.
[QUOTE=Doctor Zedacon;35278825]Uhh, why? First of all, its "She" and second of all, there is nothing wrong or broken about her.[/QUOTE] There is something pretty wrong if he's in the state of mind where he's heavily considering replacing his genitals for practically nothing instead of getting the treatment he deserves. Also, it's a "he" and he will always remain a male unless science discovers something that completely replaces the biology of a male with a female's.
[QUOTE=Rents;35283341]It is needed sometimes, for people who's mental health makes them a danger to other people.[/QUOTE] I want to say though that sometimes it should apply when someone threatens [I]themself[/I], however this would not be such a case.
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.