• Wait, what? Daughter recants rape claim; father freed after 9 years in prison
    125 replies, posted
What a cunt! First she put him in jail with false accusations and then she feels bad about it [i]NINE CUNTING YEARS AFTER[/i]. I really [b]really[/b] hope she gets barred for that.
"My dad doesn't like my mum any more, and they probably argue a lot. Curse you for splitting up!" As an 11 year old, you can understand the anger, but you'd expect her to at least feel something as she's older and knows more about how divorces work. Nope, "it was to help myself". Fucking selfish bitch
I almost wish she'd get raped for real. I don't really care what happens to sleezy fucks like her.
[QUOTE=eternalflamez;35423945]But you might as well do the thing you have been in prison for, for 9 years.[/QUOTE] No, you shouldn't
If she had come clean when she was a bit more mature (like 13-15) I would agree with no charges being laid. The fact she waited so long, even after she was old enough, even after she was mature enough to realise the full consequences and seriousness of her lie is what I think she should be punished over.
I think this raises an interesting legal situation really, she committed the crime at age 11, which is in the area of being unable to prosecute (on the presumption children don't know right from wrong enough) in Australia, but recanted it 10 years later. If I was going to make an uneducated assessment (as I always do) I'd say they're not prosecuting because of her age when she committed the crime reasoning that it best reflects laws regarding this. [editline]4th April 2012[/editline] Sucks to be the father really
I thought it was innocent until proven guilty, not guilty until proven innocent!
[QUOTE=lord0war;35425214]I thought it was innocent until proven guilty, not guilty until proven innocent![/QUOTE]He was uh, "proven" guilty.
Compensate him. Utterly unbelievable that she won't be charged for this
[QUOTE=Cloak Raider;35425514]Compensate him. Utterly unbelievable that she won't be charged for this[/QUOTE] Unfortunately I don't know if there's much they can do because of the statue of limitations and the fact that she was a minor when she committed the crime. I'm curious as to whether or not the father can file a civil suit over this though, hopefully he can.
What should REALLY be looked into is why the justice system decided to dick around so much in this case.
What I find horrible is that the prosecutor isn't going to charge her. She may be have been young and an idiot, but how does that ever protect anyone from the law? Prosecutors are supposed to charge without regards to the person, and this is just a blatant double-standard. It's either ruining lives from rape or ruining lives from false accusations at this point. I find myself more worried about the false accusations, seeing as though that's more likely to ever happen to me. This bitch was just all sorts of stupid.
In that man's shoes, i'd probably storm through her front door the day i got out and punch her lying face. She deserves some kind of punishment, the selfish bitch
What a fucking stupid bitch. She should have to go to jail for nine years. Let's see how she likes it. Who gives two shits if they think it will discourage girls from reporting crimes like that. A man just spent nine years in jail for no fucking reason.
[img]http://0.tqn.com/d/animatedtv/1/0/2/6/mayor.gif[/img] Reminds me of this
She should have to pay compensation to him for 9 years.
no one considers that maybe she didn't lie and just felt that she should let dad free? dunno it is possible.
This was a very, very stupid thing for her to do, but at this point I think it should be left up to the father whether to forgive her or not. If she isn't being charged, it's pretty much all that can be done.
I used to think people just didn't lie about this shit. What a world we live in.
[QUOTE=Sucaru67;35427641]I used to think people just didn't lie about this shit. What a world we live in.[/QUOTE] You really thought so? This happens so often I am surprised anyone can believe it doesn't happen.
Why the fuck do people still go to jail for this shit without real fucking evidence? "He raped me!" Is not fucking evidence and women have a long history of lying about this kind of shit.
[QUOTE=AceOfDivine;35427715]You really thought so? This happens so often I am surprised anyone can believe it doesn't happen.[/QUOTE] no it doesn't [editline]4th April 2012[/editline] [QUOTE=soulharvester;35427744]Why the fuck do people still go to jail for this shit without real fucking evidence? "He raped me!" Is not fucking evidence and women have a long history of lying about this kind of shit.[/QUOTE] no they don't
[QUOTE=Lazor;35427810]no it doesn't [/QUOTE] Lies about rape? Sure they do. It's just not that often someone gets busted 9 years for them.
[QUOTE=AceOfDivine;35427838]Lies about rape? Sure they do. It's just not that often someone gets busted 9 years for them.[/QUOTE] nope
[QUOTE=Lazor;35427851]nope[/QUOTE] Oh yeah, I forgot that Women never lie about this kind of stuff. *re-reads the OP* OH YEAH.
[QUOTE=SaltyWaters;35427866]Oh yeah, I forgot that Women never lie about this kind of stuff. *re-reads the OP* OH YEAH.[/QUOTE] because i literally said "never" you illiterate moron
[QUOTE=soulharvester;35427744]Why the fuck do people still go to jail for this shit without real fucking evidence? "He raped me!" Is not fucking evidence and women have a long history of lying about this kind of shit.[/QUOTE] Have you ever heard of innocent until proven guilty? A similar philosophy applies here. We cannot make any assumptions until sufficient evidence has been acquired, including whether or not someone has actually been raped. Until that point is reached, it must be assumed that the victim, no matter what, is at an equal chance of being right or wrong. Whilst yelling "he raped me" may not technically be evidence, they may be right as much as they may be wrong. So, it should not be said in a fair and just government that, simply because of past history, someone's claim is to be discounted. That is for the evidence alone to decide; until then, no assumptions can be made other than a fair claim to justice.
[QUOTE=Lazor;35427851]nope[/QUOTE] Really now? Have you never read the news about how women lie of getting raped to get their exes or someone else busted? Or how they lie of getting raped after having drunk sex at parties? While a bit less, there's also enough stories about daughters lying how their relatives raped them.
[QUOTE=AceOfDivine;35427938]Really now? Have you never read the news about how women lie of getting raped to get their exes or someone else busted? Or how they lie of getting raped after having drunk sex at parties? While a bit less, there's also enough stories about daughters lying how their relatives raped them.[/QUOTE] false rape accusations are not an epidemic. the assumption that they are is what keeps the majority of rapists from going to jail because when a women reports a rape they are automagically assume to be a liar or "deserve" it in some other way. [editline]4th April 2012[/editline] and some anecdotes about some "articles you read once" aren't proof of some trend
[QUOTE=AceOfDivine;35427938]Really now? Have you never read the news about how women lie of getting raped to get their exes or someone else busted? Or how they lie of getting raped after having drunk sex at parties? While a bit less, there's also enough stories about daughters lying how their relatives raped them.[/QUOTE] Would you mind providing some such stories, as well as compare the number of such stories with the ones in which evidence would point towards actual rape?
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.