Bobby Montoya, 7-Year-Old Transgender Child, Turned Away From Girl Scouts, Later Accepted (VIDEO) - Polidicks

[QUOTE=Metanar;33023389]By "clearing up the the situation" you of course mean bringing an irrelevant personal fact into things. I know plenty of secrets of people I've fallen out with, doesn't mean I go around telling everyone about them.[/QUOTE] He had flirted with several heterosexual guys in the community and they honestly thought he was a girl. I don't like people being mislead, so I only told the guys I knew of, plus the administration team. That's all. The other part of clearing up would be the permanent ban I put in place.

Ugh fine, I can argue that I feel what you did (and are still doing) is immature but it's not going to change your mind. Unless you can actually come up with some reasons why we shouldn't support trans individuals at any age I suggest we end this here.

[QUOTE=Metanar;33023449]Ugh fine, I can argue that I feel what you did (and are still doing) is immature but it's not going to change your mind. Unless you can actually come up with some reasons why we shouldn't support trans individuals at any age I suggest we end this here.[/QUOTE] It's special treatment that will undoubtedly be pressured to be paid for by the government. If I suddenly said I wanted to always wear a long, fluorescent pink cloth over my head there would be no room for leniency so why let somebody that is clearly a boy interact with girls in a place where they're meant to be separate? What if this becomes a normal trend and boys who clearly look like girls jump on other girls and rape them?

[QUOTE=AngryChairR;33023542]It's special treatment that will undoubtedly be pressured to be paid for by the government. If I suddenly said I wanted to always wear a long, fluorescent pink cloth over my head there would be no room for leniency so why let somebody that is clearly a boy interact with girls in a place where they're meant to be separate? What if this becomes a normal trend and boys who clearly look like girls jump on other girls and rape them?[/QUOTE] What the fuck is this? Firstly, it's not special treatment, it's a recognised medical condition/illness, and everyone gets treated for those just the same. You can't turn up one day and demand HRT and surgery, and at this young age the only thing she'll be getting is a therapist. Secondly, I genuinely have no idea what you siad in the second paragraph. It seems to be some weird gender role enforcing hyperbole. Your third point is just so dumb I'm not sure I'm actually reading it right. It looks like you're saying that supporting transgender children will lead to boys dressing up as girls and becoming rapists. Not even going to respond to this.

[QUOTE=AngryChairR;33023542]It's special treatment that will undoubtedly be pressured to be paid for by the government. If I suddenly said I wanted to always wear a long, fluorescent pink cloth over my head there would be no room for leniency so why let somebody that is clearly a boy interact with girls in a place where they're meant to be separate? What if this becomes a normal trend and boys who clearly look like girls jump on other girls and rape them?[/QUOTE] i guess if you wear girl's clothing and youre a guy, by that logic you will start raping girls.

[QUOTE=AngryChairR;33023542]It's special treatment that will undoubtedly be pressured to be paid for by the government. If I suddenly said I wanted to always wear a long, fluorescent pink cloth over my head there would be no room for leniency so why let somebody that is clearly a boy interact with girls in a place where they're meant to be separate? What if this becomes a normal trend and boys who clearly look like girls jump on other girls and rape them?[/QUOTE] This post was so dumb, it can only be done justice in a play-by-play: [quote]It's special treatment that will undoubtedly be pressured to be paid for by the government.[/quote] Baseless assumption, and irrelevant to the article. The kid's having no medical treatment, just being treated as who he is. Point is voided. [quote]If I suddenly said I wanted to always wear a long, fluorescent pink cloth over my head there would be no room for leniency so why let somebody that is clearly a boy interact with girls in a place where they're meant to be separate?[/quote] Would be interesting if people actually did "suddenly" come out about it, but the fact is that when it seems "sudden" it's because they had to hide it for a long time for fear of the social stigma. Point is voided. [quote]What if this becomes a normal trend and boys who clearly look like girls jump on other girls and rape them?[/quote] Slippery slope [I]and[/I] a strawman? Really, that's a fucking accomplishment. You're a fucking shmuck if you think boys will just start raping girls at complete random.

I just don't get where he thinks cross dressers will automatically become rapists. :v: [editline]29th October 2011[/editline] unless he was raped by one at a very early age

[QUOTE=carcarcargo;33023238]Why not just lump both boy and girl scouts together[/QUOTE] Because Boy Scouts are a discriminatory Christian organization designed to push religion on children under the guise of scouting while the Girl Scouts is a secular organization designed for girls who want to be a part of scouting [editline]29th October 2011[/editline] [QUOTE=AngryChairR;33023542] What if this becomes a normal trend and boys who clearly look like girls jump on other girls and rape them?[/QUOTE] you're just the dumbest

[QUOTE=AngryChairR;33023542]It's special treatment that will undoubtedly be pressured to be paid for by the government. If I suddenly said I wanted to always wear a long, fluorescent pink cloth over my head there would be no room for leniency so why let somebody that is clearly a boy interact with girls in a place where they're meant to be separate? What if this becomes a normal trend and boys who clearly look like girls jump on other girls and rape them?[/QUOTE] You're so sodding thick. Maybe you should do some research on how other people's mind's work outside your own.