Australian child molester Peter Scully faces death penalty in Philippines
367 replies, posted
[QUOTE=GhillieBacca;51104851]For fuck's sake, why is there always [B]that one freak[/B] who defends child molesters in these threads?
Here, have a read on what this [I]~poor abused soul~[/I] did to a little girl.[/QUOTE]
obviously making filipino children dig their own graves is just a coping mechanism
When talking about rehabilitation, we need to ask whether or not some people are worth rehabilitating
[editline]25th September 2016[/editline]
I think this guy has no worth
[QUOTE=Pretiacruento;51104883]I have only read about the infamous Daisy Destruction video, some time ago. Are you sure it's him?[/QUOTE]
Yes, and it's a series of three videos. Lots of mutilation, use of fire, hanging kids on hooks. There was always a man and a woman torturing one child at the time. There's always some fucktard that spread this shit so me and several others saw the thumbnails. Still stuck in my head.
This guy needs to be killed. Crime is deterred not by the severity of justice, but by the certainty of it
[QUOTE=proboardslol;51105133]This guy needs to be killed. Crime is deterred not by the severity of justice, but by the certainty of it[/QUOTE]
This will not deter sickos like him, not at all.
I hope it will deter some. Maybe not all, but some.
This guy is probably the sickest fuck I've ever heard of. How does someone who commits this many murders slip through the cracks for so long? The system failed here. Either the Australian or Philippine government fucked up, big time. Kids are dead because someone dropped the ball.
[editline]25th September 2016[/editline]
This is the kind of case you hear prosecutors and detectives quitting their jobs over.
[QUOTE=proboardslol;51105133]This guy needs to be killed. Crime is deterred not by the severity of justice, but by the certainty of it[/QUOTE]
Nothing will deter people like this. Killing him isn't for punishment, someone like him honestly cannot be punished, it is impossible.
It's simply removal. Permanent, guaranteed, removal.
[QUOTE=Radical_ed;51105156]Nothing will deter people like this. Killing him isn't for punishment, someone like him honestly cannot be punished, it is impossible.
It's simply removal. Permanent, guaranteed, removal.[/QUOTE]
That is so depressing, honestly
[QUOTE=proboardslol;51105163]That is so depressing, honestly[/QUOTE]
I suppose, but it's also just the way it is. Thankfully, there's one less person doing this awful shit out there.
Someone wired like him simply cannot exist in our society. There is no way to mitigate his behavior, and no way to stop him from being him. He does not feel remorse, or pity, or shame. He acts entirely outside of any bounds of any society on earth, and simply needs to be removed.
I thought the girl in the video survived? I heard she suffers severe rape and torture but doesn't die and is still alive today, but other girls unfortunately died.
I've supported rehabilitation for criminals in every thread, but this guy shouldn't be let into society again no matter what.
No human deserves death.
But I think there is a point where one should be stripped of their humanity and all of its benefits.
Why do i never see anyone in threads like these asking about or even addressing the circumstances that shaped a person like this? Just talking about killing him. like that will fix it. this guy wasn't made in a vacuum, he didn't come from another planet, he was made to be who he is HERE and by the world WE LIVE IN
[editline]25th September 2016[/editline]
[QUOTE=patrioticturtle;51105207]No human deserves death.
But I think this is a point where one should be stripped of their humanity and all of its benefits.[/QUOTE]
why?
I'm afraid to open the article, so:
Were any of his victims australian? like in "Daisy's destruction", is she Phillipino? I can imagine him getting away in SE asia, but I would figure that Australia would be more likely to bust this fucker
[QUOTE=SIRIUS;51105209]Why do i never see anyone in threads like these asking about or even addressing the circumstances that shaped a person like this? Just talking about killing him. like that will fix it. this guy wasn't made in a vacuum, he didn't come from another planet, he was made to be who he is HERE and by the world WE LIVE IN
[editline]25th September 2016[/editline]
why?[/QUOTE]
Do you not know what mental diseases are? The dude's brain was just wired funky. If we had a dearth of child molesting, decapitating, torturers then yeah the social level would be worth looking at but the guy was just fucking nuts. Why SHOULD he be allowed to exist in society?
Why do people see justice, which involves punishment and retribution, as somehow a bad thing? The reason why the death penalty and other punishments are bad is nothing to do with, in my mind, that there is anything wrong with killing, which, as in this case, is perfectly just and moral. It is because justice systems designed by humans and staffed by humans are imperfect and make mistakes which are irreversible. In a perfect justice system without flaws, the death penalty, which brings justice, would certainly be present.
[editline]25th September 2016[/editline]
[QUOTE=SIRIUS;51105209]Why do i never see anyone in threads like these asking about or even addressing the circumstances that shaped a person like this? Just talking about killing him. like that will fix it. this guy wasn't made in a vacuum, he didn't come from another planet, he was made to be who he is HERE and by the world WE LIVE IN[/QUOTE]
The foolishness of not really believing in evil.
I don't really get what benefits the death penalty has over simply locking him up for life, besides saving a little money
[QUOTE=FlashMarsh;51105236]
The foolishness of not really believing in evil.[/QUOTE]
That's not what he said. He asked why, not if. Why was he evil? How did that happen? Was he born that way or did he develop that from outside circumstances? That is what he's asking.
[QUOTE=patrioticturtle;51105207]No human deserves death.
But I think there is a point where one should be stripped of their humanity and all of its benefits.[/QUOTE]
Don't contradict yourself.
This guy is human. Don't pretend otherwise. Either he deserves death or he doesn't.
Quite frankly given his crimes I am more than happy to see him permanently removed from society in whatever way is most efficient.
[QUOTE=geel9;51105248]I don't really get what benefits the death penalty has over simply locking him up for life, besides saving a little money[/QUOTE]
He doesn't get to be around anymore.
[I](Since I've never been in that position I may be wrong)[/I]
I'd rather die than slowly rotting old in a shitty prison, and everyday fearing getting punished by convicts. I'm not an expert on the topic (or philippinian prisons) but I think locking him up for life is a far better punishment suitable for a scum like him.
[QUOTE=geel9;51105248]I don't really get what benefits the death penalty has over simply locking him up for life, besides saving a little money[/QUOTE]
Well, in this instance, the Philipines isn't the place to hold him if you want him locked away where he can do no harm. Their prisons aren't known for being very secure, and there are many ways out if you grease the right palms. Either kill him quickly and remove him as a problem, or deport him to Australia. Though I seriously doubt the government of the Philipines is going to want let him go that easily, considering what he's done.
[QUOTE=geel9;51105248]I don't really get what benefits the death penalty has over simply locking him up for life, besides saving a little money[/QUOTE]
I would rather have him die than the tax payers waste money on someone I would consider subhuman.
[QUOTE=rndgenerator;51105263]That's not what he said. He asked why, not if. Why was he evil? How did that happen? Was he born that way or did he develop that from outside circumstances? That is what he's asking.[/QUOTE]
This kind of thinking, whilst useful in the abstract and especially when considering petty crimes, ultimately leads us down a moral dead end.
This thinking ultimately implores us to strip all individuals of agency and responsibility for their actions, effectively seeing the most vile of murderers as helpless human beings spinning through time. This is utterly unsustainable in reality. The modern denial of evil (and as such rejection of justice) is possibly one of the most negative consequences of the decline of Christianity. We all tacitly know that evil exists and needs to be, and should be, punished in order to at least do some of our part to try to create a more moral world. We try and pretend that imprisonment is for other reasons - perhaps for maintaining public safety/order, or for rehabilitation, or for crime deterrence. But ultimately we don't keep old men barely capable of walking but convicted of multiple murders from 30 years ago locked up for any reasons. We all understand that this is some kind of judgement that society is making in order for justice to be best made.
Are you people seriously justifying his actions because he "may" have been molested himself? What in the fuck goes in your heads??
[QUOTE=false prophet;51105352]Are you people seriously justifying his actions because he "may" have been molested himself? What in the fuck goes in your heads??[/QUOTE]
Not wanting someone to die isn't the same as justifying their actions.
[QUOTE=Rufia;51105265]Don't contradict yourself.
This guy is human. Don't pretend otherwise. Either he deserves death or he doesn't.
Quite frankly given his crimes I am more than happy to see him permanently removed from society in whatever way is most efficient.[/QUOTE]
Yeah, I worded it pretty badly. Got a little emotional there.
But the severity of his crime and his attitude towards it make it really hard to justify keeping him alive.
[QUOTE=patrioticturtle;51105374]Yeah, I worded it pretty badly. Got a little emotional there.
But the severity of his crime and his attitude towards it make it really hard to justify keeping him alive.[/QUOTE]
Well, that's how you know if you're actually against the death penalty or if you just have a different standard.
:sick:
Fucking. [B]Scum.[/B]
[QUOTE=geel9;51105370]Not wanting someone to die isn't the same as justifying their actions.[/QUOTE]
Look, it's more humane to snuff them out than lock them away in a tiny cell for the rest of their lives, possible incurring abuse from fellow inmates.
Put it this way, would you prefer to live the rest of your life locked in a box hidden from society knowing that the world has continued on in your absence with no one ever caring that you even still exist? Why do you think mental health issues explode in prison?
This man has abused children, many children. He has raped and killed them for his own gratification. He has no remorse for this and he will never feel guilt for his actions. He is nothing more than a dangerous animal who ceased being a man the moment he touched his first victim.
He holds no ounce of humanity and protesting that he should live his life out in prison is a cruel joke to him, the families he has violated and most importantly to you for supporting caged treatment as an act to some ludicrous stance on human rights.
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.