Jessi Slaughter thread (Post new ones = get banned)
1,633 replies, posted
[QUOTE=joost1120;23528474]She just needs to learn a lesson, but not something like this. She doesn't need to die or get her life ruined. She just needs to learn that that massive ego of her could get shaved.[/QUOTE]
I agree
I went in the ban history searched permas and then BOOM! advocating raiding... advocating raiding everywhere...
BOTTOM OF PAGE, REPOSTING SO PEOPLE CAN SEE THAT GOODCAT DID NOTHING WRONG:
Since Goodcat is on my friends list on Steam, he just wanted me to say this:
[img]http://img202.imageshack.us/img202/350/steamti.png[/img]
[QUOTE]Dr.Goodcat |: Could you tell them I thought a 40 year old man saying you don goofed up and I backtraced it is funny as hell
Dr.Goodcat |: Becuase if you don't luagh at that you have no since of humor
Dr.Goodcat |: Its the old man I am luaghing at
[/QUOTE]
He wasn't advocating raiding or anything like that, he just wanted to say how funny he thought the dad was when he got his words mixed up. There is ABSOLUTELY no reason to ban him for that. :colbert:
[QUOTE=doommarine23;23528480]No, it doesn't make sense.
"I think she deserved what she got" is basically saying "I'm okay with what she got"
Meaning you are okay with it.
Either you're horribly weird with your train of thought or a very bland troll :|[/QUOTE]
I've gotten many different opinions on the subject, both here and elsewhere. You're pretty much the only one who says it doesn't make sense.
[QUOTE=Doomish;23528535]*Goodcat Defense*[/QUOTE]
You know, you're a pretty cool dude.
[QUOTE=DeVotchKa;23528584]I've gotten many different opinions on the subject, both here and elsewhere. You're pretty much the only one who says it doesn't make sense.[/QUOTE]
If you think she deserved what she got, than that means you are okay with what she got.
Simple logic really.
[QUOTE=DeVotchKa;23528460]Does it really matter? You know the bans were total bull, but you're not going to give us a rational reason why you banned them. That's more or less what this thread has become about.[/QUOTE]
I'm proud of the bans. I'm glad I did what I thought was right. I knew I would be supported by Hezzy, who I respect a great deal, and opposed by the majority of posters, who I don't. The rationale for the bans was very simple:
1) Garry never wanted FP to be associated with this kind of 4chan nonsense, but now that it's a business it's even more crucial that FP dissociate itself from that kind of thing.
2) We the mod staff happen to think that all the people who are permabanned for things they said in this thread are gigantic cockbites. And to be frank that's all the justification we need.
[QUOTE=TH89;23528607]I'm proud of the bans. I'm glad I did what I thought was right. I knew I would be supported by Hezzy, who I respect a great deal, and opposed by the majority of posters, who I don't. The rationale for the bans was very simple:
1) Garry never wanted FP to be associated with this kind of 4chan nonsense, but now that it's a business it's even more crucial that FP dissociate itself from that kind of thing.
2) We the mod staff happen to think that all the people who are permabanned for things they said in this thread are gigantic cockbites. And to be frank that's all the justification we need.[/QUOTE]
I'm curious, do you think I'm a giant cockbite? :3:
[QUOTE=DeVotchKa;23528407]For the love of the Flying Spaghetti Monster, i just told you i wasn't okay with what happened. Do you even read my posts before you come back with the same shit reworded?! She brought it upon her self. Not saying i approve of the actions taken, but she still brought it upon herself. it's like that one dude that requested the Dumb rating be removed. Now, actions taken for him weren't bad or anything, but by god did he got a Boxing. Basically, it comes down to the rule "If you put yourself in harms way, expect to be harmed"[/QUOTE]
That's pretty much how I feel about the situation, I don't like seeing bad things happen to people for any reason but if someone does something stupid and they get hurt because of it I have no sympathy for them because they brought it upon them selves.
I am an EMT, if I felt sorry for every idiot who blew his fingers off with fireworks or moron who blew them selves using a lighter as a light source while looking for a gas leak my job would be pretty depressing. I never said what 4chan was doing was right, but when people do something dumb and something bad happens to them as a result of there stupid action I automatically shut off my sympathy center.
[QUOTE=TH89;23528607]
2) We the mod staff happen to [highlight]think[/highlight] that all the people who are permabanned for things they said in this thread are gigantic cockbites. And to be frank that's all the justification we need.[/QUOTE]
That highlighted word right there is why none of what you just did was fair at all.
Your [highlight]OPINION[/highlight] is not the grounds to ban any user of any forum. Just as an example and because I've been defending him all along, Goodcat was not advocating raiding, nor did he say he was from 4Chan, and he didn't break any rules. Al he was saying was that the original situation was funny. Banning someone because you personally don't like them is abuse of your modding power and it'll just make people hate you.
[QUOTE=doommarine23;23528604]If you think she deserved what she got, than that means you are okay with what she got.
Simple logic really.[/QUOTE]
You're retarded. You've said the same thing around 4 times now and it sounds even more retarded each time.
[QUOTE=TH89;23528607]I'm proud of the bans. I'm glad I did what I thought was right. I knew I would be supported by Hezzy, who I respect a great deal, and opposed by the majority of posters, who I don't. The rationale for the bans was very simple:
1) Garry never wanted FP to be associated with this kind of 4chan nonsense, but now that it's a business it's even more crucial that FP dissociate itself from that kind of thing.
2) We the mod staff happen to think that all the people who are permabanned for things they said in this thread are gigantic cockbites. And to be frank that's all the justification we need.[/QUOTE]
I'm going to be frank. I usually respect the higher-ups on any forum i go to, but again, i've got to be frank here. Your reasons are shit. There is no justification whatsoever for their bans. In none of their posts did they condone/endorse whatever, raiding in any way. A perfect example is Bravehat, who really didn't say anything on the subject. You banned them simply because you didn't like their opinions. And that's a seriously shitty thing to do.
[QUOTE=Doomish;23528664]That highlighted word right there is why none of what you just did was fair at all.
Your [highlight]OPINION[/highlight] is not the grounds to ban any user of any forum. Just as an example and because I've been defending him all along, Goodcat was not advocating raiding, nor did he say he was from 4Chan, and he didn't break any rules. Al he was saying was that the original situation was funny. Banning someone because you personally don't like them is abuse of your modding power and it'll just make people hate you.[/QUOTE]
I love you.
[QUOTE=TH89;23528607]I'm proud of the bans. I'm glad I did what I thought was right. I knew I would be supported by Hezzy, who I respect a great deal, and opposed by the majority of posters, who I don't. The rationale for the bans was very simple:
1) Garry never wanted FP to be associated with this kind of 4chan nonsense, but now that it's a business it's even more crucial that FP dissociate itself from that kind of thing.
2) We the mod staff happen to think that all the people who are permabanned for things they said in this thread are gigantic cockbites. And to be frank that's all the justification we need.[/QUOTE]
TH89 how exactly is facepunch a buisness now? All I really know is that garry bought an office.
[QUOTE=Doomish;23528664]That highlighted word right there is why none of what you just did was fair at all.
Your [highlight]OPINION[/highlight] is not the grounds to ban any user of any forum. Just as an example and because I've been defending him all along, Goodcat was not advocating raiding, nor did he say he was from 4Chan, and he didn't break any rules. Al he was saying was that the original situation was funny. Banning someone because you personally don't like them is abuse of your modding power and it'll just make people hate you.[/QUOTE]
That made no sense at all. Should the mods be brainless zombies that just let the forum go wild? Fuck no, they should be THINKING so they can do what they signed up for. (That's keep the dumbasses out in case you forgot)
[QUOTE=Agoat;23528715]That made no sense at all. Should the mods be brainless zombies that just let the forum go wild? Fuck no, they should be THINKING so they can do what they signed up for. (That's keep the dumbasses out in case you forgot)[/QUOTE]
Oh fuck, my bro is here
Philiop:hf:Philiop
[QUOTE=Doomish;23528664]That highlighted word right there is why none of what you just did was fair at all.[/QUOTE]
Who said we had to be fair?
[highlight](User was permabanned for this post ("Worst moderator ever" - garry))[/highlight]
[QUOTE=TH89;23528724]Who said we had to be fair?[/QUOTE]
The "oh damn" meter just broke.
[QUOTE=Lucinice;23528703]TH89 how exactly is facepunch a buisness now? All I really know is that garry bought an office.[/QUOTE]
Games and software under the Facepunch name.
[QUOTE=Agoat;23528715]That made no sense at all. Should the mods be brainless zombies that just let the forum go wild? Fuck no, they should be THINKING so they can do what they signed up for. (That's keep the dumbasses out in case you forgot)[/QUOTE]
While that may be true, I'd always assumed the general rule of being a mod was that people had to be DOING SOMETHING WRONG to be banned. Apparently not according to TH89, though.
[QUOTE=TH89;23528724]Who said we had to be fair?[/QUOTE]
also a response to ^
[QUOTE=Sgt. Ace;23528663]I am an EMT, if I felt sorry for every idiot who blew his fingers off with fireworks or moron who blew them selves using a lighter as a light source while looking for a gas leak my job would be pretty depressing. I never said what 4chan was doing was right, but when people do something dumb and something bad happens to them as a result of there stupid action I automatically shut off my sympathy center.[/QUOTE]
I understand that, but she's just a naive kid... maybe too naive, who thought she could do what she did and get away with it...
Like I said before, that reason alone is why I still have my simpathy center turned on :/
[QUOTE=TH89;23528724]Who said we had to be fair?[/QUOTE]
And this is why a lot of the forum thinks your a dick and compares you to Greeman, whether they openly say it or not.. Because you're not fair and do shit because you think it's funny, or think it's right in that skewed mind of yours. If you're like this on the internet, i'd hate to meet you in real life. As Doomish said, part of the point in being a mod was to ban people for doing something wrong, like posting Shock Images. Not banning because you disagree with them.
[QUOTE=Doomish;23528751]While that may be true, I'd always assumed the general rule of being a mod was that people had to be DOING SOMETHING WRONG to be banned. Apparently not according to TH89, though.[/QUOTE]
You don't think people enjoying the supposed death of an 11 year old or the anguish brought upon her and her family is wrong?
[QUOTE=Doomish;23528751]While that may be true, I'd always assumed the general rule of being a mod was that people had to be DOING SOMETHING WRONG to be banned. Apparently not according to TH89, though.
also a response to ^[/QUOTE]
Facepunch has always been known for it's bans, you've been here long enough to know that.
Obviously I'm not a moderator, but personally I think the better way of handling this would have been to come in early on and warn us that anyone advocating raiding was going to get perma'd.
Alternately, you could have DDT'd the thread, DDT'd the other thread(s) about this, and posted a sticky saying we don't want that kind of shit on here.
Permabanning people because you don't like them just makes you look like a bad moderator.
Also, personal bit of snark: I love how this thread gets easily over 20 permabans but you do absolutely nothing about the constant flamewars caused by Glaber and his ilk.
So who's gonna watch the interview with Jessi's Slaughter's parents on Good Morning America tommorow!??!
[IMG]http://filesmelt.com/dl/29awc9g.gif[/IMG]
[QUOTE=Station15;23528807]So who's gonna watch the interview with Jessi's Slaughter's parents on Good Morning America tommorow!??![/QUOTE]
Rev up those fuckin fryers, I'll be watching that. (I won't :saddowns:)
[QUOTE=Doomish;23528751]While that may be true, I'd always assumed the general rule of being a mod was that people had to be DOING SOMETHING WRONG to be banned. Apparently not according to TH89, though.
also a response to ^[/QUOTE]
Yes, I have no problem with mods banning people for doing things that are clearly wrong but not covered by the rules but perma banning people with no warning for doing something that has never resulted in a ban before is just wrong.
[QUOTE=Panda X;23528794]You don't think people enjoying the supposed death of an 11 year old or the anguish brought upon her and her family is wrong?[/QUOTE]
so you missed the part where people were still laughing at 'ya done goofed' then
IE the image I posted earlier:
[img]http://img202.imageshack.us/img202/350/steamti.png[/img]
Nobody is laughing at the fact that Jessi may or may not be dead, nor are they laughing at the fact that 4Chan's raids were "successful" or whatever, they're laughing at the dad pretending to know what he was talking about, and people will CONTINUE to laugh at it regardless of who you unfairly permaban for it.
[highlight](User was banned for this post ("Spamming" - Mr. Gestapo))[/highlight]
[QUOTE=Sgt. Ace;23528831]Yes, I have no problem with mods banning people for doing things that are clearly wrong but not covered by the rules but perma banning people with no warning for doing something that has never resulted in a ban before is just wrong.[/QUOTE]
Okay that's a little unfair, this has resulted in bans before, but the people being banned were trying to start raids and it was almost never a perma.
[editline]09:29PM[/editline]
[QUOTE=Doomish;23528840]so you missed the part where people were still laughing at 'ya done goofed' then
IE the image I posted earlier:
[img]http://img202.imageshack.us/img202/350/steamti.png[/img]
Nobody is laughing at the fact that Jessi may or may not be dead, nor are they laughing at the fact that 4Chan's raids were "successful" or whatever, they're laughing at the dad pretending to know what he was talking about, and people will CONTINUE to laugh at it regardless of who you unfairly permaban for it.[/QUOTE]
Also this man has a serious point.
Sorry, you need to Log In to post a reply to this thread.