Domino VS Vman

Well there we have it! a editing comp. :stuck_out_tongue:
Vman’s suggestion :smiley:
He wanted non DOF verision, and I edited with SuperDOF :3

Original:
SuperDOF:

nonDOF: ]

Posed by me.

Vmans edit:

Compare original to edit: http://comparescreenshots.slicx.com/comparison/18737
Time spent: around 3 and a half hours.

Domino’s edit:

http://www.cubeupload.com/files/4a3200headshotdomino.jpg

Compare original to edit: http://comparescreenshots.slicx.com/comparison/18745
Time spent: around 5 hours.

So, which is the best? :slight_smile:

Results so far:
Vman: ||||||
Domino: |||||||||||||||||||

I personally find Vman’s amazing.

I pick…domino

I have to say Vman, due to the immense and awesome muzzleflash.

I prefer Domino’s. Vman’s edit is a little too over-the-top for my taste.

Domino’s. No doubt.

Domino, for sure.

dom’s. vman’s lighting doesn’t look as good as dom’s

Goddamn, this is a tough one. I’d have to say Vman’s.

Vman.

I DISAGREE WITH MY OWN OPINIONNNNNN

Domino, Vman’s muzzleflash is a bit too big in my opinion. I first tought it was an explosion.

Domino. More realistic.

I say Domino

his blood looks amazing and lighting is good, as in vmans, his muzzle is just to big

I liked dominos headshot is better and agree with Resistance muzzleflash too big

Domino.

Dman

…I mean Vomino.

FUCK. I CAN’T CHOOSE

vman

Ok, based on coinflip, I chose Domino

I think Vman went a little too crazy with the flash; I thought the zombie’s head was packed with PE4 or something.

Also, apart from the smoke, blur and flash it looks like the only other change was some redish colour-correction.

Domino’s also looks better because he used the really nice DoF version.

"I think you mean C4"