Which map is better?

-snip-

More detail would add to more of an immersive experience and for that reason and not that reason only, Necro, I choose you!

We’re not talking about detail. However, I do see where you’re coming from, but we are leaving that out of the picture. Mainly what I’m talking about is the environment (do you want a closed map or a more open map?), buildings (there are more buildings in rp_silenthill), good faction environment, good places for events, stores, etc. Keep in mind that we have a mapper who will attempt to add more buildings to rp_necro_forest_a1.

Presumably you have contacted the author before making any changes.